Best All-star for a short trip versus a long trip?

[emilyindisney]

Hi All!

So, I know this is definitely a pretty subjective question but I have no experience with the all-stars so I was hoping you guys could share some of yours!

Here's the plan: We may or may not be looking to add a last minute night to our trip next February before we check in to a DVC hotel. We figured because its only a night we should give an all-star a try. In 2015, we're planning a split stay between an all-star and and GF where we'd we doing 3-4 nights at the all-star. We'd like to do different all-star on each trip to work towards our goal of staying at every hotel on the property!

So, getting to the actual question- In your opinion, is there one of the hotels that stands out from the rest? Is one of the all-stars better to really live out of than the others? Is one better for just a quick experience? What are your thoughts on decor, layout, etc? Do you have a personal favorite?

Thanks!

 

[goofyintoronto]

Theyre all quite similiar. The smallest is sports. I like that resort. But my fave all stars is movies. Love the theme. The arcade is terrific, they have prize redemption! Your kids would love that. I'd go with movies since its only for one night. Your kids would love the theme and arcade.