We've stayed OKW, BRV, SSR, VGF and HHI. We like all for different reasons. Our favorite on property will always be BRV. We love the relaxed and rustic atmosphere. You leave the parks and its almost like you're not in Florida anymore. The rooms at OKW were huge and the rooms at VGF were just lovely. We loved sitting in the lobby and listening to the band play in the evenings. SSR is an easy walk to DS and with the transportation hub right there, it's easy to travel between resorts to explore or have a meal.
HHI is our favorite off property location. The CMs are awesome and the resort is themed so well. We own HHI and BRV. The theming at both resorts is so well done that it transports you to someplace magical.
Least favorite...I have to say VGF. I'd always wanted to stay there so when looking for rooms and saw availability, I jumped on it. The resort itself is wonderful but getting to and from any park using Disney transportation (other than MK) can be a bit of a trial in patience. We got stranded coming home from DS one night and had to take a taxi. People were filling the queue and no VGF buses were coming yet other resorts had 2-3 buses come in. We finally boarded the bus of a mono rail resort after 40 minutes wait only to find out they'd closed the monorail. Walking wasn't an option due to construction. Coming from Epcot, we had to stand in line twice for transportation back to the resort. As nice as the resort was, never again.