I think it depends and you should probably talk to people in your area. For us, Comcast has been so great, so wonderful, such a pleasure to have after some nasty dish people and then a useless cable company. (What kind of cable company gets to CLOSE on weekends??) The time of the switch was sucky, but Comcast upgraded the entire area to nicer, faster, better service. (Which, again, aforementioned sucky company - wasn't hard to get better!) When I had issues, they sent people out immediately. Customer service speaks English clearly! And even better, when DH was deployed and I went to NJ, they put me on a seasonal rate for the two months and restarted my cable without me even calling and reminding them. Other than the switch, and when they discovered that my wires (which were not buried by the previous cable company) had been chewed through by a dog, I'd never had service problems.