American Idol Top 20 Season 9

[Nancy]

I think that is what bugs me the most about her. She comes out each week trying to hit the high notes like Adam did and I do not think she comes close. Also I think she is trying to do the same with her style. I just do not care for her.

It's like she is thinking about how it worked for him so she is going to go for it.

I feel the same way I felt about Adam, just come out and sing..no screaming, no theatrical outfits/hair...just show your talent. He had so many songs that started out good for me last year and then he'd ruin them, IMHO.

 

[Lil Lil]

Based on tonight's performances, I think we should just head straight to the FINALE- Crystal Bowersox versus Big Mike

 

[StephyDee]

OK, here's what I don't get. Adam Lambert screeching is kindof like bell bottom jeans. They really weren't that freakin cool back then, so why bring them back. Same thing.

I have really never been ANTI anyone as much as I am ANTI Lambert, so her channeling that makes it even worse for me. I know I know, flames flames flames, there are some huge Lambert fans here. I think he's self indulgent and obnoxious, and that kinda kills it for me.

Well, honestly, I am a fan of Adam's...but hey, I know not everyone likes him, so it's okay that you think what you think. I don't mind.

In MY opinion, Adam's 'screeching' seemed controlled. Like, he knew how to use it. Even if all it was was screaming, it was stable and constant. Siobhan (sp?) can't do that at all, and she thinks she can, so she screeches...badly. She cracks and pushes so hard that it sounds like she's gonna project her vocal chords back onto Miley Cyrus' face from the force.

I know, the visual is...odd...but that's what it seems like to me!

 

[FINFAN]

alrighty then...see everyone tomorrow night...let's see who's NOT going on tour....Paige, Tim, Didi bottom 3?.....

 

[Robinrs]

Look we survived a night of listening to Miley Cyrus's toothy voice... we can survive ANYTHING!!

I'm ticked that AI has made my Tuesdays and Wednesdays nothing to look forward to anymore...

 

[bunkkinsmom]

I will be choosing the Survivor option tomorrow night, so I will have to keep up with the thread to see how things go!!!

 

[Nancy]

My tops tonight...Lee, Crystal, Aaron.

Missed Katie, Casey and Andrew so can't put them in the mix.

Bottom...Paige and Didi

 

[Bree89]

My personal ranks for the night

1. Mike
2. Crystal
3. Didi
4. Siobhan
5. Aaron
6. Casey
7. Lee
8. Katie
9. Tim
10. Andrew
11. Paige

 

[StephyDee]

Look we survived a night of listening to Miley Cyrus's toothy voice... we can survive ANYTHING!!

I'm ticked that AI has made my Tuesdays and Wednesdays nothing to look forward to anymore...

I know. I used to get so giddy when Idol would come on. Now, I sorta dread it.

Actually, I honestly look forward each week to talking to you guys on here more than the show. You're the group I can decently vent to without looks of confusion and misunderstanding (my parents).

 

[Robinrs]

I know. I used to get so giddy when Idol would come on. Now, I sorta dread it.

Actually, I honestly look forward each week to talking to you guys on here more than the show. You're the group I can decently vent to without looks of confusion and misunderstanding (my parents).

My looks come from my 17yo son...

 

[FINFAN]

Train wreck I tell, ya we SHOULD look away, but don't

 

[StephyDee]

Train wreck I tell, ya we SHOULD look away, but don't

Did somebody say TRAIN WRECK?!

 

[Bree89]

I know. I used to get so giddy when Idol would come on. Now, I sorta dread it.

Actually, I honestly look forward each week to talking to you guys on here more than the show. You're the group I can decently vent to without looks of confusion and misunderstanding (my parents).

I'm sort of the same way. I used to LOVE idol and now I just think its ok but for some reason, I just cant bring myself to not watch it! I tried it once and I ended up turning it right back on lol!

Its my sister who gives us the looks lol! She hates it when I give my opinion on a performance. She just wants me to watch the show and not say anything lol.

 

[StephyDee]

I'm sort of the same way. I used to LOVE idol and now I just think its ok but for some reason, I just cant bring myself to not watch it! I tried it once and I ended up turning it right back on lol!

Its my sister who gives us the looks lol! She hates it when I give my opinion on a performance. She just wants me to watch the show and not say anything lol.

LOL My dad is the one I wanna give looks at sometimes. If someone IMO was amazing, and did a great performance, he'll go "Geez, they better pick up their game or else they're gone. That was horrible!", and if they say something, he tries to turn it around to make it seem like they suck more.

 

[Brit17]

My top three tonight ... Adam, Kris & Danny ... oops, what a difference a year makes ... remember the good ol' days ...

 

[aprilgail2]

my order would be (if I HAD to pick one.....its hard to even put them in an order this year!!!!!)

1. Crystal
2. Casey
3. Aaron
4. katie
all the rest can go home now as far as i am concerned- one is as bad as the next.....

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

ok so if i were on this show, and they told me "you can pick a billboard #1 hit to sing" i would have a hard time CHOOSING one! here's a list of ones i'd have to choose from:

Poker Face
Whatcha Say~this could work if they did it right
Disturbia
What Goes Around....Comes Around
Glamarous
Umbrealla
How You Remind Me
Lady Marmalade
Smooth
I Knew I Loved You
What A Girl Wants
Amazed
Bent
It's Gonna Be Me
Angel of Mine
If You Had My Love
Bailamos
Truly Madly Deeply
The First Night
Un-break My Heart
One Sweet Day
Always Be My Baby
On Bended Knee
Kissed From A Rose
Fantasy
The Sign~questionable...it could be hard to sing it right
I Swear
I'll Make Love to You
Can't Help Falling in Love
End of the Road
Joyride~ on the cheesy side, but i LOVE this song!!
Black Velvet
Vogue
Vision of Love
Blaze of Glory
My Perogative
Like A Prayer
Cold Hearted
We Didn't Start the Fire
Faith
Father Figure~altho Ace sang it in season 5, i might leave it to him
Man in the Mirror
Dirty Diana
Sweet Child o' Mine
Living on A Prayer
Nothing's Gonna Stop Us Now
Alone
Bad
Mony Mony~probably not, but i LOVE Billy Idol!
Addicted to Love
You Give Love a Bad Name~Blake did it in season 6, might leave it to him too
Careless Whisper
Don't You(Forget About Me)
Hello~i would probably leave this to David Cook
When Doves Cry
Billie Jean~i'd probably leave this to David Cook, too lol
Beat It
Every Breath You Take
Total Eclipse of the Heart
I Love Rock 'n' Roll
Eye of the Tiger
Another One Bites the Dust~ ahaha! it's totally a #1 hit too!!
Stayin' Alive
Hotel California

 

[Bree89]

LOL My dad is the one I wanna give looks at sometimes. If someone IMO was amazing, and did a great performance, he'll go "Geez, they better pick up their game or else they're gone. That was horrible!", and if they say something, he tries to turn it around to make it seem like they suck more.

lol! My dad will wait to see what Simon says before he makes his decision on if he liked them or not. I'll say it was great but he'll say "Alrite! Lets see what simon says!" and if he says its bad then he'll say its bad haha!

 

[Bree89]

ok so if i were on this show, and they told me "you can pick a billboard #1 hit to sing" i would have a hard time CHOOSING one! here's a list of ones i'd have to choose from:

Poker Face
Whatcha Say~this could work if they did it right
Disturbia
What Goes Around....Comes Around
Glamarous
Umbrealla
How You Remind Me
Lady Marmalade
Smooth
I Knew I Loved You
What A Girl Wants
Amazed
Bent
It's Gonna Be Me
Angel of Mine
If You Had My Love
Bailamos
Truly Madly Deeply
The First Night
Un-break My Heart
One Sweet Day
Always Be My Baby
On Bended Knee
Kissed From A Rose
Fantasy
The Sign~questionable...it could be hard to sing it right
I Swear
I'll Make Love to You
Can't Help Falling in Love
End of the Road
Joyride~ on the cheesy side, but i LOVE this song!!
Black Velvet
Vogue
Vision of Love
Blaze of Glory
My Perogative
Like A Prayer
Cold Hearted
We Didn't Start the Fire
Faith
Father Figure~altho Ace sang it in season 5, i might leave it to him
Man in the Mirror
Dirty Diana
Sweet Child o' Mine
Living on A Prayer
Nothing's Gonna Stop Us Now
Alone
Bad
Mony Mony~probably not, but i LOVE Billy Idol!
Addicted to Love
You Give Love a Bad Name~Blake did it in season 6, might leave it to him too
Careless Whisper
Don't You(Forget About Me)
Hello~i would probably leave this to David Cook
When Doves Cry
Billie Jean~i'd probably leave this to David Cook, too lol
Beat It
Every Breath You Take
Total Eclipse of the Heart
I Love Rock 'n' Roll
Eye of the Tiger
Another One Bites the Dust~ ahaha! it's totally a #1 hit too!!
Stayin' Alive
Hotel California

I like almost every song on your list! Now if only the idols would choose them lol

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

I like almost every song on your list! Now if only the idols would choose them lol

exactly!! there's SO many songs to choose from and they all picked crap, i don't get it!!