American Idol Top 20 Season 9

[GoofyforDisney3]

When she talks she sounds like a female version of Keeanu Reeves from Bill and Ted. She just sounds like she is drugged or something.

Amen, Simon! That was a bit much.

 

[mandy200587]

Nancy you're not rabid and insane as some of the ones I've met. I did so sad about that.

 

[Lynn5700]

I really wish she'd just pick a freaking style already. I hate how she comes out as a "different" person each week. She's definitely channeling some Sanjaya w/ that hair. Eeeek!!!!

LMAO!!!!!!!! It is the Sanjaya hair, haha!!!

 

[Cat0727]

She is turning me off big time with the screech....I'm done with her because she feels the need to do it every song....like someone else I remember.....

Yep...except with her I feel like she is trying too hard to be the female Adam

 

[bunkkinsmom]

Her hair looks like it hurts....like it's screaming "HELP ME! HELP ME! ahhhhhhhh......{fades to black...again}

UGH, and she SCREECHED! CMON NOW, GIRL! Stop trying to be Adam Lambert!

OK, here's what I don't get. Adam Lambert screeching is kindof like bell bottom jeans. They really weren't that freakin cool back then, so why bring them back. Same thing.

I have really never been ANTI anyone as much as I am ANTI Lambert, so her channeling that makes it even worse for me. I know I know, flames flames flames, there are some huge Lambert fans here. I think he's self indulgent and obnoxious, and that kinda kills it for me.

 

[krcit]

I can describe the feeling when you 'hit' those notes. Pain. In my eardrums

 

[Nancy]

i don't think she's doing horrible either, but this is kind of boring too.


omg....ENOUGH with the screaming please. i had enough of that crap last season with Lambert.......

I'm right there with you on this one.

 

[FINFAN]

She looks a lot like Anna Paquin

 

[WDWRocksMySocks]

I'm off to watch LOST. I'll make sure to work on the super cool cougar thing, too. Have a great evening, ya'll!!

 

[krcit]

OMG!!! I just saw Tim's slide on the recap. I cannot breathe from laughing. There are not enough shirtless pics to make up for that!!

 

[Lil Lil]

Great...now Stevie Wonder is DEAF as well as blind after that caterwauling.

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

so i'm going thru the list of #1's and picking all of the songs that i would choose. just incase anyone cares. because i honestly think my song choices would be 100x better than any of the ones from tonight.

 

[sms]

Chat with ya'll tomorrow nite!

 

[charming23]

Her hair looks like it hurts....like it's screaming "HELP ME! HELP ME! ahhhhhhhh......{fades to black...again}

UGH, and she SCREECHED! CMON NOW, GIRL! Stop trying to be Adam Lambert!

I think that is what bugs me the most about her. She comes out each week trying to hit the high notes like Adam did and I do not think she comes close. Also I think she is trying to do the same with her style. I just do not care for her.

 

[JDUCKY]

I'm off to watch LOST. I'll make sure to work on the super cool cougar thing, too. Have a great evening, ya'll!!

Same here.


Well...'cept for the super cool cougar thing.

 

[Nancy]

Nancy you're not rabid and insane as some of the ones I've met. I did so sad about that.

No, I am not rabid...maybe insane...but definitely not rabid! LOL. I just think she is an amazing singer and have since the first day I heard her on Idol

 

[DarthKTrava]

And all they picked for the recap of Siobhan's segment was her caterwauling? Yeesh.

 

[mandy200587]

No, I am not rabid...maybe insane...but definitely not rabid! LOL. I just think she is an amazing singer and have since the first day I heard her on Idol

She's an amazing singer, just everything else leaves much to be desired sadly.

 

[Pig Pen]

I had to work late and just got caught up with the DVR. I fast forwarded thru all the Miley Cyrus stuff and the judges comments, so this is my unbiased opinion.

1. Crystal - she is a one-trick pony, but it's a heck of a trick
2. Casey - eye candy and easy on the ears
3. Aaron - surprisingly good
4. Lee - solid and enjoyable
5. Siobahn - she's an odd one, but I find myself looking forward to see what she is going to do. NOT a fan of the screech though.
6. Mike - He sang well but it felt very overdone to me. He seemed cocky?
7. Tim - Poor Tim. I like him but he's clueless.
8. Andrew - I didn't hate it, but he should have put a latin flavor on the song.
9. Didi - Between her facial expressions and the annoying song, I had to fast forward thru this one.
10. Katie - Unplug your nose, for goodness sake.
11. Paige - OMG that was awful.

 

[Brit17]

Yep...except with her I feel like she is trying too hard to be the female Adam

exactly ... but at least Adam's "screams" were on key ... she really needs to get her own identity and stop trying to copy Adam ... there will never be another Adam ..