American Idol Season 9 Thread

[npmommie]

Does anyone know the number to vote? or am I too late?
I want to vote for Casey

 

[HunnyPots]

Casey and Andrew - the only guys I have any interest in at all. I really like Andrew the best but Casey is a hometown boy so he'll get my votes as well. Actually, I thought Casey was better tonight but I have liked Andrew more in the past. He has some youtube videos that my son showed me and I was impressed. Hope he loses the nerves and does better next week.

 

[oregondaddyof2]

Casey was absolutely amazing... I can see him going all the way to the finals... I bet Kara hopes he stays around a while

 

[Tess]

Interesting Dial Idol results. . .

 

[sunlver]

I havent read all the replies from last night. I was actually disappointed in Ellen. I LOVE Ellen I TIVO her show everyday..but she seemed like just a repeat of what the others said, and she never said anything original.Now granted the boys werent much better then the girls

 

[charming23]

I agree last night was lackluster as well. Although after last season it is going to take a lot to impress me.

I did like Casey, he picked the right song to fit his voice and looked good doing it.

I agree that Todderick was trying to be all like Adam but failed. Although Adam tweeted last night that he really like Todderick and thinks he'll be in the cmpetition for a long time. So who knows.

 

[golfgal]

My ears STILL hurt from last night. This has to be the worst top 24 ever. There isn't a single contestant that you sat back and said "WOW". It's going to be an interesting season.

 

[kimmar067]

My ears STILL hurt from last night....

...mine are still bleeding....

 

[kimmar067]

Looks like Vote for the Worst is putting up Tim Urban....

...well, Simon didn't like him...

 

[kimmar067]

Since I just started watching, I got to see Casey and Andrew....

...I like Andrew Garcia too...

 

[kimmar067]

i genereally like longer hair on men, so that doesn't bother me. i mean i think he's ok looking but he's no Ace or David Cook!!

....why does Kara think he looks so hot with his shirt OFF???!?

 

[Jennasis]

I'm with ya there. I love David Cook as well but his album just does not compare to Adam's. I'm hoping DC's next one is an improvement.



And here I said I was gonna watch the Olympics and DVR Idol. You guys are just too much fun!

Respectfully, I LOVE Adam Lambert. But his album just sucked out loud. It's no comparison to David Cook's, IMO. I was so disappointed with Adam. Waited andwaited for his album to drop, put it on my ipod and then THAT'S what I got. Barf. David Cook is just awesome...could listen to his album over and over!

 

[kimmar067]

Respectfully, I LOVE Adam Lambert. But his album just sucked out loud. It's no comparison to David Cook's, IMO. I was so disappointed with Adam. Waited andwaited for his album to drop, put it on my ipod and then THAT'S what I got. Barf. David Cook is just awesome...could listen to his album over and over!

...I knew there was something about you that I liked...

 

[Jennasis]

...I knew there was something about you that I liked...

 

[MA pigletfan]

ughhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh sooo disappointed! What is going on this year? I really think that since Simon is leaving next year..that might be the end, at least for a while. Maybe all the undiscovered talent is sucked up for now, or at least the ones that want to take part of this show!
I did like Casey and Andrew..but even they didn't make up for it being so boring..ugh
Results should be interesting..I have no idea who should go since about 10 from each side are worthy candidates!

 

[cruiserkaren]

Respectfully, I LOVE Adam Lambert. But his album just sucked out loud. It's no comparison to David Cook's, IMO. I was so disappointed with Adam. Waited andwaited for his album to drop, put it on my ipod and then THAT'S what I got. Barf. David Cook is just awesome...could listen to his album over and over!

Wow I'm absolutely at the opposite ends of this! I adore "For Your Entertainment." Can't get enough of it. But only have 3 songs from DC's album on my ipod. I love DC's voice but just did not love that album. That's actually the reason I passed on seeing him live. I'm holding out hope for the next one though!

Results at 8 or 9 tonight?

 

[KiKi Mouse]

so.....he should change his clothes, so he can sound better??

i hate when they talk about their outfits or their hairstyles/make-up ......that's not what the show is about.

and when we first saw Tyler, he was wearing that stuff and no one said anything about it then, but NOW it's a problem??

not like ANY of those judges have any room to talk about style, to begin with...

I don't get why they commented about his clothes when that is something that they loved about him when he first auditioned.

I like him and I like his Jagger swagger and I hope he is able to really find himself in the next couple of weeks. Yeah he needs to bring his songs up to date instead of doing a retro thing...that way he will get the young vote too.

I didn't like the comments about Tim? when they said he might get the girl votes and then how they commented about Casey? saying he was eye candy.
Isn't this about singing and star appeal???

 

[Kirby]

I havent read all the replies from last night. I was actually disappointed in Ellen. I LOVE Ellen I TIVO her show everyday..but she seemed like just a repeat of what the others said, and she never said anything original.Now granted the boys werent much better then the girls

But she will speak up if she disagrees. She disagreed with Simon about Todrick last night if I'm remembering right.

This may be Simon's last season but he is really in form. He was almost cruel to a couple of the guys that I saw last night before I had to leave. But, then again, he is almost always dead on.

 

[Kirby]

I don't get why they commented about his clothes when that is something that they loved about him when he first auditioned.

I like him and I like his Jagger swagger and I hope he is able to really find himself in the next couple of weeks. Yeah he needs to bring his songs up to date instead of doing a retro thing...that way he will get the young vote too.

I didn't like the comments about Tim? when they said he might get the girl votes and then how they commented about Casey? saying he was eye candy.
Isn't this about singing and star appeal???

You know, sometimes I think that their negative comments are made to swing our votes in favor of certain contestants. Sort of a reverse psychology effect.

 

[kimmar067]

....HEY-Y-Y-Y! You don't know me THAT well!