American Idol Season 6: The Official Thread

[JunieJay]

Man, I am BUMMED out. I thought Nick had one of the best voices in the competition. I just can't believe other people didn't hear what I was hearing.

 

[flipturngirl]

Okay so I have not posted on here for a while.. AHH! Okay I really like most of the girls.. I like only a couple guys.... Chris Sligh...someone else... who is it.. and Sanjaia... (okay I know that most people hate him but I think he is adorable.. well maybe because I am a 18 year old girl... but)

I hope that this season is good! I really like how it is tuning out so far.

 

[Nancy]

Cheesy group song...can they go back any furthur to find a song?

Nick is gone...no big surprise. Nice voice but not Idol material.

 

[mandy200587]

thank god she's gone

 

[nannerbadnanner]

Melinda Doolittle = Lily Tomlin with a tan

Leslie = Erin from The Waltons

 

[Robinrs]

Okay, they were WRONG with the girls, at least on the percentages, not the raw numbers.

 

[plgrn]

If Sanjaya doesn't get sent home, I am going to throw something.

I'm right there, between Sanjanya and Antonella they better be gone or I might throw a shoe.

Count me in! Guess I'll just throw the first thing I can grab.

 

[Robinrs]

Omg how embarrassing...

 

[Nancy]

No surprise with the girl either...I thought a few were worse, but she wan't all that good...and she just dised Simon!!

Ryan repeated what Simon said and she said "clever"

 

[nannerbadnanner]

Omg how embarrassing...

Seriously! I feel bad for her!

 

[dolphindan1]

I'm right there, between Sanjanya and Antonella they better be gone or I might throw a shoe.

find somethingcause they will both be staying...I feel the same about Brandon maybe dialidol will be wrong like it was about Alaina

 

[plgrn]

Is it just me or does anyone else think it's kinda sick and cruel to make them sing again when they are kicked off. It's humiliating.

 

[flipturngirl]

*coughing* okay sorry about that.. I think that sme of the people need to go but not all. I just wish that everyone could win.

 

[Reflection]

Oh well, if turns out that Wantonella/Anton-never (love that moniker) does not get the boot tonight, at least Alaina is gone.

 

[Nancy]

Seriously! I feel bad for her!

Me too...How hard it must be to sing when all you want to do is cry.

 

[Philadisney]

this is probably the most emotional results show i have ever seen, and we're only halfway through it! I can't believe how much Sundance is crying...a lot of them seem pretty upset actually...aw
I wonder what happened with the sound too, at one point there was a BOOM! and Alaina looked surprised and I had no sound for 10 seconds or so.

 

[flipturngirl]

Is it just me or does anyone else think it's kinda sick and cruel to make them sing again when they are kicked off. It's humiliating.

Well I think it is just to remind people what they will be missing out on in the future.. But you are right it is sick and cruel.. but it is also sick because they are trying to poll the ratings up.. you know that people at home are either.... or or

 

[Reflection]

Is it just me or does anyone else think it's kinda sick and cruel to make them sing again when they are kicked off. It's humiliating.

Especially when they did not perform their song well in the first place. If Alaina's rendention last night was anything like what she did this evening--that is cruel and unusal punishment to my ears.

 

[Obi-Wan Pinobi]

I missed it - what was embarrassing?

 

[Philadisney]

Well I think it is just to remind people what they will be missing out on in the future.. But you are right it is sick and cruel.. but it is also sick because they are trying to poll the ratings up.. you know that people at home are either.... or or

I think that all the contestants should have a 'just in case i get kicked off' song prepared to sing, so that we can still hear them sing one more time, and it can be different than last night.