American Idol Season 6: The Official Thread

[mandy200587]

I had to pick up my daughter from dance class and missed a couple of the singers. What did Wantonella sing, and was she dreadful?!

I will say this as nicely as possible. Thank your lucky stars you missed it!

 

[dolphindan1]

I will say this as nicely as possible. Thank your lucky stars you missed it!

I didnt think she was the worst tonight I thought 3 or 4 did worse tonight that Antonella....JMHO

 

[mandy200587]

She butchered a classic. My ears are still hurting from that note.

 

[rcraw45425]

I had to pick up my daughter from dance class and missed a couple of the singers. What did Wantonella sing, and was she dreadful?!

Because you Loved Me

 

[Robinrs]

I had to pick up my daughter from dance class and missed a couple of the singers. What did Wantonella sing, and was she dreadful?!

She warbled "Because You Loved Me" and dreadful would've been a step up.

 

[Nancy]

Stephanie sounded like she was way off from the music..I think she came in late.

Leslie...was doing ok till she got to the scat part...didn't work for her at all, plus she is so spastic in her facial movements, I can't watch her.

Sabrina..thought she screamed the song and didn't sing it.

 

[Jerseylicious]

Man, Lakisha is just TOO awesome!! It's like she was BORN to sing like that! What an amazing voice.

Melinda is up there with her too, however...and I do like Sabrina too. None of the others compare to them, IMO.

 

[DisneyMommyMichelle]

Loved Lakisha again! I also like Gina and the doolittle gal!

 

[DisneyMommyMichelle]

oooo Antonella was just awful! definately the worst of the night! DH and i were cringing!

 

[Minnie]

Lakisha and the doolittle girl where the tops of the class again

Antonella was beyond awful - hurt my ears to listen to her - Simon was right just as bad if not worse than last week. But the scary part is VFTW may keep her there for the laughs.

However who in the world dressed Lakisha - they should be fired The orange shirt/orange background and on top of that a mini skirt on a gal that size????????????

Doolittle was definitley dressed better. The shoulder pads are gone which is a good thing

 

[r3ngels]

I think ... if there is a God... Antonella should be going home. I think Leslie, Hayley and maybe Alaina will be joining her this and next week.

I wanted to like Hayley and Alaina but they aren't as strong as the others. I really like Jordin, she may not be the strongest singer but she is a great singer and seems like such a doll and amazing for such a young girl.

I know this has been said before but it REALLY is a shame that they break up the boys vs. girls because Hayley and Alaina aren't great but better then some of the guys.

 

[r3ngels]

Great minds think alike....

I gotta work on my signature...i was contacted by the signature police....I would sure hate to think someone complained about it....

Dan... can we vote for the pics that we want to stay... We will do it AI style.

 

[Philadisney]

ooooooooh mellllllllinda....she got most of my votes tonight. way to take one of my favorite songs and do it in a unique way....
i also threw some votes leslie's way, just 'cos i like her. she's FUN! i have a feeling we'll be kissing her goodbye tomorrow, though. c'est la vie!

 

[agnes!]

Both Alaina AND Antonella had BAD attitude, lots of eye-rolling and someone stuck her tongue out at Simon, I didn't record the show, I think it was Alaina. She is a big NO just on her la-di-dah attitude. Simon gets a bad rap, but more often than not, I actually agree with him. I'm a performer and I DON'T appreciate it when someone who's auditioning me for something WASTES my time. Do NOT shine me on, don't blahblahblah. I think I'd rather have it cut & dried, I mean REALLY...does Paula ever say..."You were dreadful" and why can't Randy just cut to the chase and say "You were off-key"? Pitchy...PITCHY?!? The singer is OFF-KEY and is inventing some new keys never before heard by man!

The girls just were not as strong tonight as they were last week. I'm afraid to look at DialIdol.com tonight...In my book Sanjaya should be GONE and Antonella/Alaina should be gone too.

agnes!

 

[jaimee1024]

Didn't Stephanie sing a Beyonce song? If so, then I don't think she came in late...I think that's how Beyonce's songs are. The lyrics never seem to go with the music. I find it very difficult to listen to. I thought Hayley was much better than they gave her credit for. I thought she was pretty good tonight. But there are three that are in my opinion head and shoulders above the rest. Melinda, Lakeisha and Jordin. I like Sabrina too, but didn't think she was as good tonight as she was last week.

 

[ColoradoBuffaloMom]

I agree-overall not as good this week as last week but the girls are still better than most of the guys.

I love LaKisha's voice but that outfit has to go. It's just not her. I really like Jordin and Sabrina.

I would have a very hard time singing right after listening to a dedication I just did so no wonder some of the contestants are plugging their ears as they play the dedications for the audience.

Can't wait till tomorrow.

 

[BoosGram]

I loved LaKisha last week, but tonight Melinda RULED. Wow, goosebumps on my arm.

And how I wish they would ban Celine's songs altogether. Forever.

A note to the PP who matched the boys' pictures w/lookalikes. Thanks so much; I laughed so hard I fell off my chair. (That batboy one is sooooooooo funny, poor Phil.)

 

[lillygator]

so who's gonna call me tommorrow? We'll be at Whispering Canyon for dinner when they announce the vote offs!!

 

[Nancy]

so who's gonna call me tommorrow? We'll be at Whispering Canyon for dinner when they announce the vote offs!!

You could always cancel the dinner...afterall whatv is more important?

 

[lillygator]

You could always cancel the dinner...afterall whatv is more important?

I was all for getting a Pizza!! I had a Boma res, then that didn't go over well so changed to WCC tonight.....