American Idol, Season 5 **Official Discussion Thread** Part 2

[DVC Sadie]

Chris was the guy on the left. The other guy was a Colin Farrell wannabe from Bullseye.

 

[Lisa loves Pooh]

What the heck was Meatloaf smokin'?

Such a great song and he just made it suck so bad!

 

[ktpool]

Kat and Meatloaf??? I LOVE Meatloaf...they should have sung "Paradise By the Dashboard Lights". Although, admittedly that would be kinda creepy.

 

[Lisa loves Pooh]

Maybe he's trying to get her sing off-key.

 

[kdibattista]

LOVED Puck n Pickler

Hate Kat n Meatloaf

 

[LoraJ]

What the heck was Meatloaf smokin'?

Such a great song and he just made it suck so bad!

it's like the Broadway version or something lol!

 

[Reflection]

Yikes, but Meatloaf should not be singing a Celine Dion song!

 

[Poohbear123]

What the heck was Meatloaf smokin'?

Such a great song and he just made it suck so bad!

He gained ALL his weight back.....he looks and sounds AWFUL!!!!

 

[lbgraves]

Is Meatloaf sounding like that on purpose????

Katharine should get an award for singing with him & being able to sound good.

 

[MickeyMouseGal]

Ummmm... why are Kat and Meatloaf singing a Celine Dion song? And very badly?

Whatever happend to Anything for Love??? They should have sung that!!!

 

[Lisa loves Pooh]

Kat and Meatloaf??? I LOVE Meatloaf...they should have sung "Paradise By the Dashboard Lights". Although, admittedly that would be kinda creepy.

Well since you can't drink and drive, that would be best that they didn't b/c he sounds freakin' drunk or something.

 

[disney1990]

Do you think that each finalist decided who they wanted to sing with? Makes sense for Paris and Chris -- but Kat?

 

[Sandy22]

Besides the fact that Kat and Meatloaf seemed to be singing in the wrong key with each other, I think Kat sounded fantastic! Too bad for her she didn't sing like that last night.

 

[Reflection]

He gained ALL his weight back.....he looks and sounds AWFUL!!!!

He was not just 'pitchy;' he was full-blown off key!

 

[Lisa loves Pooh]

Ummmm... why are Kat and Meatloaf singing a Celine Dion song? And very badly?

Whatever happend to Anything for Love??? They should have sung that!!!

maybe he wouldn't let them have the rights to it. You know--so he wouldn't have to screw up his own song live on air.

 

[aplejax76]

Ok, This is just painful to listen too. Where is the fork so I can jam it in my ear? It has got to feel better then listening to this painful song.

 

[sweet angel]

Chris and Live were amazing!!!!!!!

 

[Lisa loves Pooh]

LOVED Puck n Pickler

Hate Kat n Meatloaf

Of course now my oldest keeps asking me why the guy was making her eat snails.

 

[Lisa loves Pooh]

Do you think that each finalist decided who they wanted to sing with? Makes sense for Paris and Chris -- but Kat?

Ryan referenced that Al and Live were their idols. I wonder if Kat's was not available and someone tried to throw her under the bus with Meatloaf and his drunk karoke.

 

[JoenAdamnErinnSam]

FYI- Jim Steinman wrote the song they sang-he wrote alot of Meatloaf's music-and Meatloaf has recorded it-and yes-he sounds that way on purpose-to each their own.