As a kid I always wanted to stay at the contemporary. The monorail went through it on our way to MK. Nothing was more magical than that mural followed by the first views of the Magic Kingdom.
As we left the parks we passed over the Polynesian, but I really barely noticed it. It looked nice, but it wasn't "WOW!"
But then I grew up and realized the Contemporary wasn't my idea of well, contemporary. Certainly at one time doors that opened on their own were wondrous, but now? meh. For some reason we find it pretentious more than anything.
DH, on the other hand, never went to Disney as a kid. IN far this first trip was OUR first trip with our oldest whens he was 9 months. After that he fell in love with the idea of staying at the Poly. But it wasn't really doable so we stayed elsewhere happily.
Then last trip we booked at CBR for a

vacation. And then the specials were announced and It was only going to cost me $500 more to stay at the Poly than at CBR. I weighed the pros and cons, but decided against surprising DH with an upgrade. Instead we talked it over and he reluctantly agreed (he doesn't do change well).
We arrived and it was wonderful. We loved it.

Oh there were little things mind you, but it was wonderful. Until we went to Capt Cooks.
That place was horrible! I left in tears b/c the manager was so rude. We vowed never to return. (I also vowed to complain, but I didn't do that).
It also looks like that other vow won't stick since we've booked again! We talked about various options and we settled on purchasing AK DVC. We told our girls and they were beyond upset. "YOu mean we'll never stay at the Polynesian again?!" Needless to say we didn't have the answer they wanted. The Poly was their favourite resort and they couldn't bear to stay anywhere else. So if all goes according to plan, well be back at the Poly in Sept.