If they truly dropped the ball, I could see complaining, but if it's something that needs to be fixed to keep the pool functioning and safe, I wouldn't be asking for anything. Every day is someone's "once in a lifetime" at WDW, whether it's the hotel they booked, the ride they hoped to ride, the pool they wanted to use or even the trip itself.
If it were a ride or a restaurant closed, I wouldn't care. But the large, themed pool with a slide is one of the things that makes a Deluxe resort a Deluxe. It is one of the things you are paying the bigger price tag for. So, yes, if it is closed the entire time, even if it was unplanned, I would ask for some sort of compensation. I'm not going to throw a hissy fit in the lobby, but if I paid for something and didn't get it, I'm going to raise the issue.
To me, it would be no different than booking a suite and when you get there, all the suites are under construction, so you must stay in a regular room. You wouldn't still expect to pay for a suite, would you? Or going to dinner at Cinderella's castle and none of the princesses are there. I would definitely want some of my money back.
The pool is a HUGE feature for this resort and one of the big reasons why we chose it, along with location.
If it were a ride or a restaurant closed, I wouldn't care. But the large, themed pool with a slide is one of the things that makes a Deluxe resort a Deluxe. It is one of the things you are paying the bigger price tag for. So, yes, if it is closed the entire time, even if it was unplanned, I would ask for some sort of compensation. I'm not going to throw a hissy fit in the lobby, but if I paid for something and didn't get it, I'm going to raise the issue.
To me, it would be no different than booking a suite and when you get there, all the suites are under construction, so you must stay in a regular room. You wouldn't still expect to pay for a suite, would you? Or going to dinner at Cinderella's castle and none of the princesses are there. I would definitely want some of my money back.
The pool is a HUGE feature for this resort and one of the big reasons why we chose it, along with location.
Will you be staying through the July 4th holiday? Several folks here (myself included) will be there at that time.
After being here a week we are checking out tomorrow and heading home. What a WONDERFUL stay in Hawaii! I am definitely spoiled with the CL now and enjoyed every minute of it!
If funds allow it again I will DEFINITELY stay CL again!

it was me!! I was the begger!! Those pics are gorgeous! Exactly what I was looking for! That shaded table on The beach looks very inviting! 
