Great thread and the pics are gorgeous!!
I'm so excited that I can now contribute to this thread! We just got back from a stay at the Poly 1/29-2/5, and LOVED it!! I had read so many mixed reviews, but FWIW, here's my take:
Check-in was a breeze. I did online check-in, and was the only person in that line, so it took just minutes.
Just after check-in, I had my first encounter with the outstanding Disney service. My DD5 decided she didn't want to sit in the car while we were unloading the bags, so she stealthily took off. When we couldn't find her, I ran back to the GCH and asked the online check-in CM if she had seen her. She remembered her name and description, and immediately called security, who tracked her down within minutes! I couldn't thank them enough for helping us resolve that very scary situation.
We let the tiki gods choose our room, and ended up in Tokelau.
We paid for garden view, and what we got was a 2nd floor balcony that overlooked the foliage in the middle, the quiet pool to the left, and the lagoon to the right. We could see Wishes and the Electrical Water Pageant from our balcony.
Mousekeeping was great the entire week, and the room was clean and without obvious wear and tear.
We ate at each of the restaurants, and all were very good.
Every CM was friendly to a fault, and never failed to greet us with "Aloha!".
I can't say enough good things about the Poly! Thanks for all the info this thread provides for newbies like me!!