I am soo happy someone started this thread! Thank you, thank you, thank you! Hopefully we can all keep it going! I love the All Stars and have always wanted them to have their own FAQ thread! LOL!
My tips:
1.) Don't pay extra for Fantasia if you don't absolutely have to be within steps of the pool. We were in the Toy Story section Buzz Building and we would walk to the bus stop from the sidewalk there to the front without going through Cinema Hall. It's a closer walk than from the Fantasia buildings.
2.) If you get there early like we did (9:00am) and you've faxed your room request but aren't given what you had wanted first thing... don't give up! We had faxed in our request for connecting rooms in the Toy Story section. However at check-in we were told that we were to be put in the Love Bug section. Not that it's a bad section but my 7 year old niece loves Toy Story soo much and has since the original movie came out... we were soo dissappointed. We just asked the CM if she was sure there wasn't anything else available. She pecked around on the computer and said the only other thing she had was two non-connecting rooms in the Mighty Ducks section. Okay we were all very dissappointed and told the lady so. We were not rude to her in the least we just let her know how much we were looking forward to sleeping next to Buzz & Woody!

We didn't see how all of the rooms in Toy Story could be taken at 9:00 am. She told us to hold on a second and went into the back room. She was gone for probably 10 minutes. When she came back she had 2 connecting rooms in the Toy Story section for us!

We were soo excited.
I'm not saying that this would work everytime but give it a try if you don't get what you request the first time. I wanna say again that we were not rude and hateful with the lady in the least... we just told her how dissappointed we were and I think she could see that. Also, we wouldn't have been as vocal if it had been closer to check in time. We were early and I think that helped to! Just wanted to post this in case it would help out anyone!
3.) Do not hesitate to book at ASMO! You will not regret it! It has the best Disney Atmosphere of any hotel I've stayed at there! We never felt like we left the magic behind at the parks. We all always got these big smiles on our faces when we'd walk through "Andy's Room" to our room each day! I've stayed at DxL too and like a previous poster said it just didn't have the WOW factor for me either. Plus I hated to layout of the place and the bus service was awful.
The bus service is excellent at the ASMO! We were even there during a very crowded Easter week and we had no complaints.
The food court has a really nice selection! We loved it. Ate there almost every day when we came back to our room to rest in the afternoon.
Also the CMs are soo great! They always seem to be in the best moods! I swear I think that the place just seems to bring out the best in everyone there! LOL!
4.) Have a great trip! You won't regret booking at ASMO!
Okay where do I get my Official All Star Movies Cheerleader uniform?? 