For our goodbye to Disney dinner, I managed to snag us the coveted 7:00pm dinner ADR at Le Cellier.
We showed up a few minutes early and waited about 15 minutes to be seated. We were led to a four top table near the center of the room. The interior is very pretty, and true to its name, looks like a wine cellar. I love the wood beam ceilings and stone walls.
Our server greeted us promptly and introduced herself as "Jess from Yellowknife". She was very cute and bubbly and I loved her accent!
While we were perusing the menu, Jess brought us out a basket of the famous Le Cellier bread - soft pretzel sticks, along with two other kinds we never touched.
That pretzel bread is soooo good. I could just eat a meal of that!
I had a really hard time deciding what to order. I had tried the Cheddar Cheese Soup at F & W festival before and loved it, but I wasn't feeling like eating a heavy appetizer and meat that night. So I went with the
Tomato Stack appetizer, with caramelized onions, cucumber, blue cheese, and yuzu vinaigrette:
This was a really excellent way to start the meal. The tomatoes were nice and ripe, the caramelized onions were sweet, the cucumber light, the blue cheese pungent, and the yuzu vinagrette is a great finish. It's very unexpected with a tomato dish and provided a sweet, tart, and citrusy finish. It really hit the spot for me.
Mark didn't order and appetizer, but started with a glass of Estancia Cabernet Sauvignon. Sorry, I didn't get a photo, but I guess you guys know what red wine looks like.
For our entrees, Mark went with the
Salt-crusted Prime Rib - with Roasted Yukon Potatoes finished with au jus and horseradish cream sauce.
He ordered the prime rib medium-well, but when the plate came out the juices were still red. He cut in to it and it was almost raw inside. (Looked yummy to me
) but it was definitely not cooked how he ordered it. Jess from Yellowknife was by our table again quickly to check on things and had the dish promptly replaced in about 10 minutes with one that was cooked the correct medium-well.
I tasted this and it had a lot of fat on it. If you found some of the meat, it was good, but nothing spectacular. Mark seemed pretty pleased by it though.
I went with the
Mushroom Filet Mignon - with wild mushroom risotto, white truffle and an herb butter sauce.
(Hey I just noticed - there's a hidden Mickey in that photo!
)
The smell of truffle coming off of this dish was intoxicating. It was so earthy and pungent! My steak was cooked a perfect medium-rare, just as I had ordered it. The meat was good, but again, nothing to really write home about. I don't have any complaints about this dish, but nor did it really wow me. It was like a filet you would get at an Outback Steakhouse on a good day. The risotto was nicely done, very creamy and tasty, but this is a very heavy dish and I didn't finish all of it.
For dessert, Mark went with another glass of Cabernet.
I knew months in advance what I was getting though -
Maple Creme Brulee!
This was VERY tasty! The top was nicely bruleed, not undercooked or burnt, and had a satisfying crack when hit with the spoon. The inside was a bit more pudding-textured than I would have liked, but the taste was awesome. I love maple, and I love creme brulee...so it would have been pretty hard for me to not like this dish.
So, do I agree with the Le Cellier hype? Not really. It's a good meal, in a nice, setting, with great service, but amazing steaks? Umm, no. I would, however, return again - but not order any steaks. I love the cheese soup, and the appetizer and dessert were quite good. Next time, I will have an appetizer, cheese soup and pretzel bread as an entree, and a dessert. I think if you want a truly great steak at Disney, you really have to go to a signature.
7 out of 10.