Always homemade - I always use extra fruits - whichever floats my boat ever year - and I make mine very tart, so I go under the sweetener level recommended. My family LOVES the homemade sauce, so much that I am now never allowed to skip it.
Since it does not occupy the "sweet" at our dinner, but the "sour", I've now started rotating either a pumpkin or sweet potato dish in to fill in as "the sweet"...
This year, I have pear nectar to use for some of the planned water, so I'll be using pears and/or apples as my combo with the pear nectar and plenty of crans...