The apples haven't been allowed as snacks on the DDP ever. They were always above $4 once they had that rule and before that they just had the very restricted list. It will be interesting to see which of these manage to stay as snacks. They always seemed to be such a good snack value and it took so long for them to get made it seemed like one of those things where high demand but low capacity to make them would doom them to get off the snack list.