I agree that we don't have enough info yet to judge this in its entirety.
But when I hear things like "if you don't like you can just do what you did before", I cringe. Disney is spending a LOT of money on this system. They are going to expect a significant return on their investment. This means 1, it will need to have a price tag associated with it, and 2, it will need to provide a strong benefit to justify that price tag.
This mean xpass users are going to have to have it a lot better than the rest of the guests, and that means everybody else is going to be worse off. Fewer FPs available, longer standby lines, etc. The only real question is how big the impact will be. So I don't think it's fair to just say "if you don't like it don't use it". Those guests are going to be negatively impacted and therefore have a right to express their displeasure.
At least that's how I see it.
+1000.
I am aware I am a minority on these boards. Always stay offsite, hence no ADR's (Do eat onsite during the day though) and little in depth planning. I understand that others have more of a stake in this, but that doesn't change the fact I am NOT happy about this.
I understand the benefits but for me it has major issues...
1) Longer lines, I don't trust those estimates one inch, for one thing there can be wild variations in crowd numbers based on weather and time of year, and I dont think they have factored this in adequately. I would estimate 10-15mins increase in peak season for major attractions. That is just opinion however.
2) Decreased FP numbers = chaos imo.
3) Even more competition for non-xpass/fastpass line spots/show spots = even more hopping/jumping/abuse of the normal system (Guest behaviour fault, not really Disney, but an issue nontheless.)
4) I suspect they will bump other prices. Suspect. Especially merch/park tickets. In the long run this new system might pay off, but given the amounts involved, I would expect them to be in a hurry to recoup that investment, something I can't see happening if it isnt widely adopted, hence the need for increased prices elsewhere.
Honestly, whilst I appreciate that others stay onsite and pay more into disney, I feel the need to vent about this. It isn't up my street at all...
We will just have to wait for the facts. I can't help but think however that this will be a PR and financial disaster.