We are non-DVC owners who are renting points for a stay in january. When this deal came out yesterday I was like, 'ugh we could have gone for a lot cheaper but it's too late to cancel now!'
I did the math and later realized that yes, we could have stayed at a value resort for less money, but figuring the deal based on our accomodations (2 bedroom at OKW) we are still saving more money off rack rates by renting than we would with this discount. Based on my calculations, the total cost per night (including park tickets for each person) is about $50 cheaper when renting, even when you factor in the $200 gift card. Not to mention the fact that we were only going to go for five nights and this deal requires seven.
Great Job comparing apples to apples

Im not staying in a Value or Moderate for 7 days. Im not going to the parks for 7 days straight either. We've seen this deal before, but it was a better deal when the tickets were Park Hoppers. MYW Tix allows WDW to strip them down to the basics and they are front loaded.