I am legendary with my in-laws for regifting really bad gifts. We have a grab-bag gift exchange every year at Christmas. I had gotten a Christmas toilet seat from another gift exchange several years before. I loved it and used it every year, but then we moved to a new house with different-sized toilet seats. Well, I had to put that toilet seat in the family gift exchange. I cleaned and sanitized it well, and DH's step-sister ended up with it and loved it. All was well until DH tattled that it was used. I haven't lived it down since. And now even though I reassure my in-laws that my gifts are freshly purchased for the exchange, they don't believe me and steer clear of whatever I bring! (Thus, I always buy something I want, as I know I'll be taking it home!) :