I am also really on the fence about this. I have seen the show twice. The first time we had a terrible view and didn't really care for it (the original show) therefore did not have any interest in seeing it again. My daughter wanted to see it again this year, so we got yellow FPs and went early to get a rail view. We both really enjoyed the show (Christmas version). Not that we liked one show over the other, I think it was just so much better when you can see it. Haha! I am going with my husband in October and I think he would like it, but neither one of us are keen on getting there at least an hour early, sitting on the ground for 1/2 hour then standing shoulder to shoulder with other people trying to crowd in and shoving their kids in front of you.
So we were thinking of trying the dining pkg so we could get there 10 mins before the show and get at least a decent view. We're not crazy about the menu at Carthay Circle but have a reservation here since we like Wine Country Tratoria and what we like isn't on the WoC menu. But if we won't have a decent view getting there late, I'm not sure what to do.