We've done multiple stays at WL...over 10 trips and one to the villas in a studio....
We're empty nesters and got a good offer from Disney to try the villas in a studio......first impression......wonderful......room seems larger, wet bar, alittle larger fridge
Second impression after unloading our stuff and getting over the day of travel...not so wonderful.....these are are own impressions.....small amoire (really got used to the flat screens of the regular Lodge)...one queen bed and the sofa sleeper got to be a pain to pull out and make up and not comfortable....the kitchenette was not really that helpful in any way same goes for the bigger fridge (we do fine with the normal fridge they provide in the Lodge)...also, we pool lounge alot, mid day and late night and there's hardly anyone at the villa pool...we sort of like the antics around the main pool and to get there is a good walk....same goes for the Roaring Fork..we do dine there alot, and refill our mugs constantly and it was just too far from our villa to do so.......
From all our stays we prefer the north wing of the resort for closeness to the QS, boat dock and pool (though the pool is eaqsily accessable from either south or north wing)....we found that staying in the villas, we used the bus more than the boat for transportation leaving the resort....boat dock is a long walk from villas.....and for us the boat is the reason we stay at WL...
Okay, to sum it up....since we frequent the WL more than many....we do prefer the regular lodge over the studio villa....just based on convenience and location and what we are used to......but don't let this post turn you away...it was just our feelings from previous trips and staying in the north wing with a quick elevator ride down, right at the RF and out the door to the pool plus quick route to the boat dock for the MK FW and CR.....guess call it creature habits, we like and prefer the Lodge over the villas....