We stayed offsite for our first two trips to WDW, and I hope to never stay offsite again!
We just returned from a stay at the Wilderness Lodge, and I had been reading positive things about this resort for years. Before we left, I was hoping that the WL would live up to the hype, and guess what?
It did and then some! I loved this resort! The theming there is incredible!
Some people prefer to stay in a 2 room suite offsite for the same price (or less) as you could onsite.
But for us, there is no comparison. I'd rather stay onsite in a one bedroom than offsite fighting the traffic coming onto WDW property.
Part of our vacation is not only the theme parks, but the themed resorts as well.