Who's Being Unreasonable?

I am not suggesting a woman shouldn't go places without a husband. I am merely stating my opinion that I don't think families should take vacations apart.

Maybe if I hunted or fished, I would feel differently. But since I am extremely co-dependent, I would be highly irate if my wife took my kids on vacation without me. In that instance, my wife would be being unreasonable.

Since I don't know this woman or her husband, I can't say, in the context of THEIR relationship who is being unreasonable. So I used the standard of MY relationship instead.

But this is not about you. She did not ask "would you think it unreasonable if your DH wouldn't let you take the kids out of the country at Christmas," she asked if her DH, who doesn't care if she takes the kids away, is being unreasonable. Me, I wouldn't want DH to take the kids without me if I had to work, at Christmas. DH, he wouldn't mind a bit if I took the kids under these conditions. I happen to be a lot more selfish than he is, and he is not a huge fan of Christmas (but fakes it pretty well).

Some people have such a hard time accepting that people have different priorities than themselves. Not all couples are co-dependent on each other. I'm needier than my DH, but he's selfless enough to put up with me! :cool1:
 
I love spending time with my husband, too. :) They are not mutually exclusive.

You are right they aren't. I just don't like being told that it is sad that I don't vacation without hubby. We aren't glued 24/7. He does things without me and I without him, including going out of town. I visit family in Orlando for a day and he will take youngest DS to his out of town soccer tournaments without the rest of us so he can have one on one time. He has also done this with the other 2 kids for a weekend. But regular vacations, no, we like to do those together. Frankly up until recently, there wasn't anyone that I wanted to travel out of town with, I have many friends but none that I wanted to spend days with. The group I am going with this time is great and we want to take a trip together, other than that, nope not interested. thanks anyway.
 
Another thing to consider is that since 9/11 some people are leery of overseas travel or being at the mercy of a plane to get home. I know that the threat of terrorism would make me nervous to send DH out of the country with the kids. Doesn't mean that I don't trust him just means I'm nervous. Right or wrong that's how I feel, maybe OP's dh feels the same way:confused3
 
Why would you find that sad? She could just as easily say it's sad that you married someone you apparently don't enjoy spending most of your time with, but she didn't - probably because she realizes different things work better for different people. My parents never took separate vacations during the almost 45 years they were married. They certainly weren't together 24/7, but they did spend most of their free time together. They enjoyed being with each other and were best friends. Being together is what made them happiest. The fact that it doesn't work for you doesn't mean that it's sad.

I love spending almost all of our mutual free time with my husband as well. I happen to have more free time than he does--so we (the kids and I) travel during times that he is working out of town. Back when he did shift work, if he had a busy week and would need lots of daytime sleep (when the kids were too young to really understand to be quiet so he COULD sleep), we also traveled. It had nothing to do with not wanting to spend time with him and everything to do with wanting to enjoy the the time in spite of the sadness of not being able to spend those days with him (even if we stayed home).
 

Why would you find that sad? She could just as easily say it's sad that you married someone you apparently don't enjoy spending most of your time with, but she didn't - probably because she realizes different things work better for different people. My parents never took separate vacations during the almost 45 years they were married. They certainly weren't together 24/7, but they did spend most of their free time together. They enjoyed being with each other and were best friends. Being together is what made them happiest. The fact that it doesn't work for you doesn't mean that it's sad.

Thank you, very well said.
 
I love spending almost all of our mutual free time with my husband as well. I happen to have more free time than he does--so we (the kids and I) travel during times that he is working out of town. Back when he did shift work, if he had a busy week and would need lots of daytime sleep (when the kids were too young to really understand to be quiet so he COULD sleep), we also traveled. It had nothing to do with not wanting to spend time with him and everything to do with wanting to enjoy the the time in spite of the sadness of not being able to spend those days with him (even if we stayed home).

Well, that WAS me also. Mine worked shift work, which included all the holidays that I mentioned. We would do things during the day, little trips to Orlando to see family or across town to see mine. I didn't want to drag 3 small kids around with me, one was very ill and it just wasn't possible. Now he is home, works from home and because of all the time he was gone we don't want to vacation without each other, I know alot of families that do and that is fine, but just tell me (and I know it wasn't you) that it is sad because we don't like to vacation without each other.
 
I love spending almost all of our mutual free time with my husband as well. I happen to have more free time than he does--so we (the kids and I) travel during times that he is working out of town. Back when he did shift work, if he had a busy week and would need lots of daytime sleep (when the kids were too young to really understand to be quiet so he COULD sleep), we also traveled. It had nothing to do with not wanting to spend time with him and everything to do with wanting to enjoy the the time in spite of the sadness of not being able to spend those days with him (even if we stayed home).


I can understand that. I've traveled without my husband as well, even though I do prefer to spend my time with him. I was just responding to the other poster's assertation that it was sad that mhsjax doesn't vacation without her husband. I was trying to point out that those sorts of statements don't work, because different things work better for different people.:) I thought I explained that in the part of that sentence you didn't bold, but maybe it didn't come across as well as I hoped.
 
What I have learned from this thread-

1. Traveling w/out a spouse is sad.
2. Traveling with a spouse is sexist.
3. Traveling at Christmas is sad.
4. Not traveling at Christmas is sad.
5. Passports are easy to renew.
6. Passports are difficult to renew.
7. If you think something is irrational everybody must think it is irrational or they are irrational.
8. The Bahamas seem like a nice place to travel to at Christmas.
9. When a spouse doesn't want you to travel out of the country with the kids they are controlling.
10. When a spouse doesn't mind if you take the kids to the moon they don't care.
11. It is a horror to leave anyone at Christmas.
12. It is a horror if you don't want to leave anyone at Christmas.


I am sure I am forgetting something but I think I covered it. ;)

OP- whatever your setup for the holidays is is irrelevant. Your dh seems to have a reason why he doesn't want you to go. Maybe you need to figure out exactly what it is. I tend to think it is more than the passport issue. Of course- who knows? Either way, keep your family's opinion out of it. That will not add anything nice to the conversation with him. Good luck in whatever you plan to do.:goodvibes
 
Another thing to consider is that since 9/11 some people are leery of overseas travel or being at the mercy of a plane to get home. I know that the threat of terrorism would make me nervous to send DH out of the country with the kids. Doesn't mean that I don't trust him just means I'm nervous. Right or wrong that's how I feel, maybe OP's dh feels the same way:confused3

He did bring up 9/11 and people being stranded. ::yes::
 
What I have learned from this thread-

1. Traveling w/out a spouse is sad.
2. Traveling with a spouse is sexist.
3. Traveling at Christmas is sad.
4. Not traveling at Christmas is sad.
5. Passports are easy to renew.
6. Passports are difficult to renew.
7. If you think something is irrational everybody must think it is irrational or they are irrational.
8. The Bahamas seem like a nice place to travel to at Christmas.
9. When a spouse doesn't want you to travel out of the country with the kids they are controlling.
10. When a spouse doesn't mind if you take the kids to the moon they don't care.
11. It is a horror to leave anyone at Christmas.
12. It is a horror if you don't want to leave anyone at Christmas.


I am sure I am forgetting something but I think I covered it. ;)

OP- whatever your setup for the holidays is is irrelevant. Your dh seems to have a reason why he doesn't want you to go. Maybe you need to figure out exactly what it is. I tend to think it is more than the passport issue. Of course- who knows? Either way, keep your family's opinion out of it. That will not add anything nice to the conversation with him. Good luck in whatever you plan to do.:goodvibes

:rotfl:

Thanks! I had to LOL at your list! Who knew we could learn so much in just a few hours?!
 
What I have learned from this thread-

1. Traveling w/out a spouse is sad.
2. Traveling with a spouse is sexist.
3. Traveling at Christmas is sad.
4. Not traveling at Christmas is sad.
5. Passports are easy to renew.
6. Passports are difficult to renew.
7. If you think something is irrational everybody must think it is irrational or they are irrational.
8. The Bahamas seem like a nice place to travel to at Christmas.
9. When a spouse doesn't want you to travel out of the country with the kids they are controlling.
10. When a spouse doesn't mind if you take the kids to the moon they don't care.
11. It is a horror to leave anyone at Christmas.
12. It is a horror if you don't want to leave anyone at Christmas.


I am sure I am forgetting something but I think I covered it. ;)


13. Asking a bunch of strangers on the internet who don't know you or your family for their opinions on your Christmas vacation is going to be a trainwreck no matter WHAT. :lmao:
 
Originally posted by Mouse House Mama -

What I have learned from this thread-

1. Traveling w/out a spouse is sad.
2. Traveling with a spouse is sexist.
3. Traveling at Christmas is sad.
4. Not traveling at Christmas is sad.
5. Passports are easy to renew.
6. Passports are difficult to renew.
7. If you think something is irrational everybody must think it is irrational or they are irrational.
8. The Bahamas seem like a nice place to travel to at Christmas.
9. When a spouse doesn't want you to travel out of the country with the kids they are controlling.
10. When a spouse doesn't mind if you take the kids to the moon they don't care.
11. It is a horror to leave anyone at Christmas.
12. It is a horror if you don't want to leave anyone at Christmas.

:yay: Well, that's the DIS for ya!

To the OP - as I mentioned earlier in this thread, my DH also works rotating shift works. He happens to be working midnights this week. So, when he got up this afternoon & was getting ready to go back to work, I asked him if he would mind if I took the kids & went on a cruise to the Bahamas over Christmas w/ my parents & my sister's family if he had to stay home & work. His answer actually surprised me a little -

DH: I would like to think I would tell you to go, because I wouldn't want ya'll to miss out on an opportunity just because I had to work.

Earlier I had thought/assumed he wouldn't want us to go because he would want to be w/ us to see our children first "experience" of the Bahamas. Like I asked before, I don't know if that may be the real issue for your DH or not. Maybe he wants to be w/ your kids when they see something for the first time?

Anyway, my DH surprised me!

But he did wonder why your & your kids' passports are up-to-date & your DH's passport is not.

Still, I'd have a hard time leaving my DH at Christmas (even if he were working the whole holiday), but I do realize that people are different!
 
:yay: Well, that's the DIS for ya!

To the OP - as I mentioned earlier in this thread, my DH also works rotating shift works. He happens to be working midnights this week. So, when he got up this afternoon & was getting ready to go back to work, I asked him if he would mind if I took the kids & went on a cruise to the Bahamas over Christmas w/ my parents & my sister's family if he had to stay home & work. His answer actually surprised me a little -

DH: I would like to think I would tell you to go, because I wouldn't want ya'll to miss out on an opportunity just because I had to work.

Earlier I had thought/assumed he wouldn't want us to go because he would want to be w/ us to see our children first "experience" of the Bahamas. Like I asked before, I don't know if that may be the real issue for your DH or not. Maybe he wants to be w/ your kids when they see something for the first time?

Anyway, my DH surprised me!

But he did wonder why your & your kids' passports are up-to-date & your DH's passport is not.

Still, I'd have a hard time leaving my DH at Christmas (even if he were working the whole holiday), but I do realize that people are different!

Thanks for asking your DH...interesting answer! I'm actually a little surprised my DH freaked out like he did.

To answer your question...older DD has been to the Bahamas and on a cruise, so he's not really missing a "first" for her, maybe the baby. My daughter has experienced plenty of things/places without Daddy, and although I'm sure they'd love him to be there, she loves telling him all about her "adventures" when she gets home.

BUT, I did ask him about the possibility of going earlier in the week so he could go with us, and he wasn't too interested - just kept suggesting we do something else. Spending any length of time on a ship with my family isn't exactly his idea of relaxing, I guess! :laughing:

And by the way, my passport is expired as well, and the kids don't have them. We don't need them to cruise (I know it's a good idea to have them...but that's another debate we don't need started on here!) :)
 
Thanks for asking your DH...interesting answer! I'm actually a little surprised my DH freaked out like he did.

To answer your question...older DD has been to the Bahamas and on a cruise, so he's not really missing a "first" for her, maybe the baby. My daughter has experienced plenty of things/places without Daddy, and although I'm sure they'd love him to be there, she loves telling him all about her "adventures" when she gets home.

BUT, I did ask him about the possibility of going earlier in the week so he could go with us, and he wasn't too interested - just kept suggesting we do something else. Spending any length of time on a ship with my family isn't exactly his idea of relaxing, I guess! :laughing:

And by the way, my passport is expired as well, and the kids don't have them. We don't need them to cruise (I know it's a good idea to have them...but that's another debate we don't need started on here!) :)

OK, I change my vote, and man that won't go on a cruise, well, have a great Christmas at the Bahamas. :thumbsup2
 
:yay: Earlier I had thought/assumed he wouldn't want us to go because he would want to be w/ us to see our children first "experience" of the Bahamas. !

Have you been to the Bahamas? It's not like he's missing their first experience in Paris! :rotfl2: My kids were amazed that there are poorer places than even Newark or Camden, NJ!
 
Why would it be strange that her DH passport expired and hers didn't? My DH had a passport before me, so ours expire at different times. My DS also doesn't have one and he went on a cruise, just needed his BC
 
He did bring up 9/11 and people being stranded. ::yes::

This was my first thought. My kids (high school age)both went half way accross the U.S. on a trip so DH and I were considering going on a cruise while they were gone. I couldn't bring myself to do it. Having land between us seemed easier. Even though I could have flown to them just as quickly or more so from where we'd be I just couldn't do it. Not necessarily rational, but that's how I felt.

It's not just about the kids. It's about needing to have some feeling of control in case something happened to his entire family. Having them somewhere he can't drive to probably just feels to scary. Feelings aren't always rational. Sometimes it's just better to give a loved one peace of mind.

The most nervous I get about my family's safety is when they are all together without me. If I think about it, it's easy to get worried.
 
Well, that WAS me also. Mine worked shift work, which included all the holidays that I mentioned. We would do things during the day, little trips to Orlando to see family or across town to see mine. I didn't want to drag 3 small kids around with me, one was very ill and it just wasn't possible. Now he is home, works from home and because of all the time he was gone we don't want to vacation without each other, I know alot of families that do and that is fine, but just tell me (and I know it wasn't you) that it is sad because we don't like to vacation without each other.
Oh i see that side too---it just seems this thread has a lot of either one or the other only is okay and no in between. I do not think there is anything wrong with people who always vacation together and I do not think there is anything wrong with those who travel separately. It seems like most of the opinions on this thread are falling in the camp of there is something very wrong with anyone who does not vacation as they do. You know, you do not love you spouse if you dare to travel without them OR you are too needy/dependent if you do not want to travel without them. It just seems everyone has different circumstances and it doesn't have much baring at all on how much we love our spouses or how much we enjoy spending time with them


I can understand that. I've traveled without my husband as well, even though I do prefer to spend my time with him. I was just responding to the other poster's assertation that it was sad that mhsjax doesn't vacation without her husband. I was trying to point out that those sorts of statements don't work, because different things work better for different people.:) I thought I explained that in the part of that sentence you didn't bold, but maybe it didn't come across as well as I hoped.

It kind of came across, but also really felt to me like you meant it. Sorry I misunderstood:flower3: It was late here when I read that and maybe I was not thinking as clearly as I should.

:yay: Well, that's the DIS for ya!

To the OP - as I mentioned earlier in this thread, my DH also works rotating shift works. He happens to be working midnights this week. So, when he got up this afternoon & was getting ready to go back to work, I asked him if he would mind if I took the kids & went on a cruise to the Bahamas over Christmas w/ my parents & my sister's family if he had to stay home & work. His answer actually surprised me a little -

DH: I would like to think I would tell you to go, because I wouldn't want ya'll to miss out on an opportunity just because I had to work.

Earlier I had thought/assumed he wouldn't want us to go because he would want to be w/ us to see our children first "experience" of the Bahamas. Like I asked before, I don't know if that may be the real issue for your DH or not. Maybe he wants to be w/ your kids when they see something for the first time?

Anyway, my DH surprised me!

But he did wonder why your & your kids' passports are up-to-date & your DH's passport is not.


Still, I'd have a hard time leaving my DH at Christmas (even if he were working the whole holiday), but I do realize that people are different!

This is a moot point as the OP has since explained that none of them have passports; however I think it is worth pointing out this is pretty common. DH and I both already had passports when we got married. They expired at different times then and thus still do now. The kids got theirs as infants and used to expire at different times but we let DDs go a bit in between twice to get to a point that they are at least on the same schedule now. These things are pricey so I can see if you were not likely to travel for a while doing as we did with DDs and not renewing right away too (which might leave only one person in a family without a valid passport).
 
OP you have to have the long conversation with the hubster about this. You have to find out why this is such a problem for him.

It might just be the passport. It might be more. Dig deep to really work this out. :goodvibes

With us, we're allowed to be unreasonable, but we have to OWN that. If DH doesn't want something to happen, we'll talk for a few days, and if it comes down to a case of "I just don't wanna", then that's his reason and we can work from there. Same for me.

DH would trust me and be OK with me traveling alone with DS to just about any place on the planet *that I would feel comfy traveling to in the first place*. He KNOWS I'm not about to go to the Sudan, I'm not going to go to Iraq or Iran (though I know a guy whose family has (or had, in '95) the main AC factory in Jordan, so maybe someday I'll visit there..."anyone know Ibrahim?", but that's not going to happen any time soon), I'm not going to go to either of the poles, north or south, and I won't go to many other places due to lack of interest.

On the other hand, he wouldn't be OK'd for takeoff to take DS much of anywhere. Part of that is irrational, and we both know it. The other part of it, however, is that all but one of DS's big injuries have been while DH has been right there, watching him. And the one exception actually was his call, but I was closer physically and went along with DH's decision. DH knows darned well that I have a higher degree of "keeping Eamon safer" than he does. There's also the aspect of they look nothing alike to strangers, and he would be seriously questioned *everywhere*.

But we can't just do one-liners. There has to be conversation, to worm out all of the real reasons buried in our hearts.


Apple and oranges. Taking your kid to the movies and taking your kid to another country are completely different.

Yep. Taking them to the movies in America is likely as dangerous or MORE dangerous than traveling abroad to many countries would be... :3dglasses


He and I haven't discussed renewing his passport yet, but it can't just be renewed because it's been expired for awhile. He'd have to go through the whole process again...

Not a big deal at all. I renewed mine, sent it in 2 days after DS's was sent in...I got it 2 WEEKS after DS got his.

But how long has it been expired. YOu can go 5 full years beyond expiration date and still have a renewal allowed. How do I know? I went 4 years 11 months and 3 weeks after mine expired and got the renewal. Got the passport in '95, it expired in '05, got it renewed in '10.

I would never leave DH for christmas even if he had to work. We would spend the time before and after work together.

Even if were a tiny bit of the main issues, she's said that he'd be awake *maybe* an hour after getting home from work. An hour!


:confused3 According to what the OP has explained numerous times, the father also feels it is totally acceptable for the kids to not be there during Christmas *as long as their trip takes place within the borders of the United States*. If it is unreasonable to have one's kids away from one on Christmas, then she and he are equally unreasonable, no?

I really don't understand why posters continue to act as if the OP is being mean to the husband by thinking of taking the kids on the trip when that is something which (according to the OP) he agrees she should do!

Is the idea that the OP is simply lying about what her husband has said about the trip within the U.S.? Or is everyone assuming that the husband can't/won't say what he is really feeling/thinking? Or are people not actually reading what the OP is saying?

Omg your username! :rotfl:

I agree with what you wrote.


He did bring up 9/11 and people being stranded. ::yes::

Of course, that would be an issue no matter where you were, if it was more than an easy car ride away. If something like that happened again, he *could not get to you* easily. It's a matter of fact. Heck, it could be difficult just to get *home* after work, if something big happened. As people of this warlike earth, we have to get used to that...like the gazelle isn't guaranteed safe passage through the veldt...we aren't guaranteed anything, either.

Not sure I recommend bringing that up to him NOW, of course... Just like should never EVER have mentioned the breakdown that I had, and the reasons why, after watching Bounce, to my friend who was in the hospital nearly at death's door and to her husband (who, it turned out, was already on his way out of the relationship partially b/c he couldn't handle her chronic illness), it's likely better to save the above conversation for later.


Oh i see that side too---it just seems this thread has a lot of either one or the other only is okay and no in between.

Well I'm perfect for that! A Libra by birth, a "see both sides" person by nature (took me 30+ years to start having opinions).

DH and I were *extremely* codependent for the first part of our relationship. Never wanted to travel apart, so that if something happened, we'd both die. Felt that we'd do that when we had kids, too (have the whole family travel together). That was especially so for the concept of DH being left behind...while I would *want* very very much to die after such a thing, I am fairly certain that DH *would* die if something horrible happened to me and/or DS.

And then DH got this job. That has him, for instance, boarding a plane tomorrow only to come back the next day. That had him in Korea 3 times just since Spring. He flew to Tokyo on Dec 26th...the bosses said that he should go a few days later, but what the heck do we care about the dates? GO! It's mission critical for what he does, GO! (I got much kudos for that) He was here for his b'day, but missed DS's b'day, missed our anniversary. He said he will probably be here for my b'day, but I'm not holding my breath. He's done this work for over a year, and what we've found is that there are very FEW dates in our lives that we feel he *has to be here for*. Actually, there's only been one. And it was solely because I live for the company's summer picnic, and they almost sent him out for that day (we can't get in without him!). It was that day or our anniversary, so we made sure he was in town for the picnic, then he flew out the next day and missed our anniversary.

My brother and sister in law have realized, with their busy careers (that they LOVE), that dates are just dates, and things can be celebrated any time.

Of course, you have to be faced with a layoff and then the realization that contract work, even with Microsoft, can really suck, when you have a family, to get to the place where you realize dates are just dates. You have to have a job presented to you on a platter, a job that's very important to the company and the product you're supporting, a job that WILL take you away quite a lot of the time, to realize that just about every celebration can be rescheduled.

And it helps if no one's particularly religious in the immediate family. :upsidedow



Anyway, we used to be glued at the hip. And now I am back to being my old independent, self-sufficient, happier self, and he's remembering what it was like to travel (his family moved all around Asia when he was young)...he's scoping out places for us to visit in the future and getting some FF miles LOL. DS is the one that likes it least, but he's of the strong opinion that I should go off and do this job, and leave hubby behind. But I am wise to them and know it's b/c hubby would cave and buy a videogame system, and I'd come home a week later to find them still on the couch with their eyes glazed over and repetetive stress disorder on their thumbs, LOL. That's IF DS manages to avoid major injury...it would be DH watching him after all! :upsidedow

So I've been on both sides. :)
 
Have you been to the Bahamas? It's not like he's missing their first experience in Paris! :rotfl2: My kids were amazed that there are poorer places than even Newark or Camden, NJ!

Remember how Bubba could name 1001 ways to cook up shrimp in Forrest Gump? I swear, Bahamians can come up with more ways than that to cook conch. :lmao:

It's not up to me to say whether your DH is unreasonable or not. I will say all our passports expire at different times. Also, I have taken DD to England when she was 4 and left DH at home, taken her to Norway at 5 and left DH at home and will likely haul her within the next year or so to Europe again....just the two of us. We have time off...He doesn't. All post 9/11. DH is as much of a worrywart as the next daddy, so he'd make sure his passport was in order so he could get to us ASAP if needed.

Good luck.
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom