I don't think you would be disappointed w/ either one. We love them both that we flip flop each year. This year it's the Hoop Dee Doo for us.
The food was good at both places.
One thing to watch is that the SOA is outside (kind of, it's covered on the top, but not the sides). We went last October and it got chilly at night. We were lucky to have our sweaters.
I know you will enjoy either one!