Which ship?

[coloradogirl13]

HI, I have already booked my cruise but I was just wondering, which ship do you think is the best?

 

[mark & sandra]

The Magic, simply because if you're on it you're on a longer cruise!!...Mark

 

[Lloyd Dobler]

My vote goes to the Magic, just because it sails longer itineraries. I really don't think there's a lot of difference between the two. I'm more familiar with the Magic, having only sailed on the Wonder once. If they both sailed similar itineraries, I don't think I'd have a preference.

 

[Otimon]

With the exception of decor and different names for the club area and a couple of restaurants, both ships are the same. If you've been in one, you've been in the other! Love them both

Have a wonderful time.

 

[KMovies]

While the longer cruises are nice (Magic), I find the decor of the Wonder a bit nicer (I find Route 66 a bit nicer than Beat Street, Wave Bands a bit nicer than Rockin' D Bar).

Really, it is simply that the decor of the Magic is 99.95% and the Wonder is 99.975%.

Maybe being just one year newer (Wonder) makes a difference as well.

Question: For the finale of Disney Dream's - isn't the pixie dust on the Wonder more than the Magic. It seems that on the Magic is on the side walls and the Wonder it is the side walls and the ceilings? I've always thought that there was a difference there. For that one reason, I like the Wonder better as that is so Magical, I mean Wonderful.

 

[wide awake]

During Dreams pixie dust is on the Magic ceilings. Just saw the show last week and thought the pixie dust segment was great.

 

[sanddune]

I like Magic more. I like Mikey in the lobby and Goofey hanging off the back of the ship. I also like the decore better.

 

[coloradogirl13]

THis is kind of off topic but also which ship have you been on the most?

 

[Kaa]

I prefer the decor on the Wonder. I have never really cared for Art Deco and I like Art Noveau. I have been on the Wonder twice and on the Magic 5 times.

I do prefer Helmsman Mickey to Ariel - so I like the atrium on the Magic more.

 

[Pea-n-Me]

I the Wonder but am looking forward to trying out the Magic which I'm sure I'll love too!

 

[coloradogirl13]

Wow, I guess that alot of people like the magic better?

 

[WDWLVR]

I voted neither. I love them both.

Magic - I love the Mickey statue! Plus it is the original. I love that they do the longer cruises.

Wonder - I love the mosiac in Triton's so much more than the mural in Lumiere's. I also like the entertainment district more on this ship.

They are both winners in my book! We've been on the Magic 3 times and the Wonder twice. Have one booked on each for the future.

 

[logan1_2000]

Add my vote to the others who selected the Magic simply because we get to stay on board longer for the longer itineraries. Offer me a longer cruise on the Wonder, and I'll change my vote to neither (which should be expressed as "tie--they are both my favorite").