I have stayed at both (cbr 2x, por 3x) and I love them both!
Cbr is lush and green and we love the beaches with lounge chairs and hammocks. We also love it that each "village" has its own quiet pool, beach and bus stop.
It has a zero entry main pool with several slides, as well as the height redtrictef splash area for younger kids. I think for kids under 10 this is the best pool on property. Although my teenagers had fun at that main pool too, but I do think its a bit geared to younger kids. Which.is why the large quiet pools are so nice.
The rooms are the largest moderate rooms by a bit and every bit can count when you have a family in one room!
I love having a very good view of the high up fireworks of Illuminations from various places around the resort. Dh and I enjoyed sharing a hammock on the beach in Jamaica last March to view the stars and it was also a good spot to see those fireworks. It was heaven!
Negatives are few, but I will mention that it only has the double beds and I think the foodcourt is too small and lacks enough variety (good food though. All in all, we love cbr!
Por is probably my favorite resort. Love the theming, the river and the grounds. In my opinion, it has the best foodcourt on property. You also have pofq's food court a short walk or boatride away. We love the main pool, its got a longer slide than cbr's but only one slide.
We love the boatride to dtd, its a very pretty ride.
All rooms have queen beds and have been recently refurbbed.
My few negatives are that I find the layout confusing, some areas in the Alligator Bayou section are remote to say the least. I also think it could use a few more quiet pools. So while I give the edge to POR for its main pool (I have older kids), I give CBR the edge for the quiet pools.
We love both, both are spread out and have multiple bus stops, we have had no problems with bussing at either. Both are laid back with lovely grounds.
I think either is great, but if you have young kids, the pool at cbr is hard to beat (not that por's pool isnt also fun too). Por's recently redone rooms with queen beds are also hard to beat!
Posted from DISboards.com App for Android