Which ADR would you drop?

[TinkerbelleAbbysMom]

So I finally got a Le Cellier lunch time for out trip!! But now that means I have to cancel one. We are taking my mother/brother-in-law with us so I want to give a good variety. On the other had DD4 wants to have brkfst with the princesses, Lilo and Stitch and Donald! She enjoyed the CP breakfast last year but some of us going aren't big into bkfst so we switched to dinner at CP. So anyway, here is my list, which would you drop?
Tony's (lunch mon)
Akershus (bkfst tues)
Le Cellier (lunch tues)
Ohana (bkfst wed)
SciFi (4:15p wed)
Mama Melrose (thursday) - I have a 2:45 - was of course hoping for f! package but no luck so far. I know last year while there, they were giving the F! tickets to other tables who weren't F! packages.
CP (dinner sat)
Tusker house (bkfst last morning)

Are there any that you think the food/service are consistently bad? Of maybe character interaction is poor? I can say we won't cancel Akershus or Le Cellier for sure! I had chosen the Sci Fi one b/c DBIL would like it. He isn't very picky but I think he would think it's cool.

 

[silmarg]

Personally I think Le Cellier is overrated. I know I am in the minority on with this opinion, but maybe mine was a bad experience.

But to answer your question, Tonys to me has nothing special to offer and I would drop it.

 

[Nadjalu]

LeCellier is good, if you are a lover of beef, if not it can be overrated.

But if it is important to hit this restaurant then I would lose either Tony's or Sci-Fi.

(since you are eating Italian at Mama Melrose, Tony's is the logical choice).

Have a good trip!!

 

[jturling]

If you need to cancel one because of dining plan.I would pay out of pocket for Sci-Fi and keep your ADRs.Sci-Fi prices arent worth using a TS credit for.We really enjoyed going there.

 

[disneybex]

We loved Sci-Fi, so much so that we returned for another visit on our last trip, so I'd say keep that.

I would cancel Tony's, it always seems to be hit and miss with both the service and the food - we had awaful service on our last trip.

 

[mirage0306]

I would drop Tony's.

 

[momto2inKC]

I would drop Tonys. We really enjoy Le Cellier, everytime we've ate there the food and service have been great!

 

[minniebride]

I would drop Mama Melrose, unless that is your only choice for dining at DHS. It's not very them-y and the food is mediocre.

We actually had a great meal at Tony's! Service was good, food was good, atmosphere was really pretty.....also great view of the parade if you time it right. We thought it was alot of fun to eat on Main St!

 

[sue_gowin]

I love all your ADR's, but if I HAD to pick one, it would be Tony's. Unfortunately, we haven't had great experiences there...at least not as great as the other restaurants you have on your list!

 

[Karlzmom]

Tony's and SciFi were the 2 worst meals we had in 4 seperate trips. You could easily drop either and have no regrets. The movie setting is cooler than Tony's so I'd probably drop Tony's given the choice, but in reality I'd drop both and pick something else...like 50s PTC!

 

[Miss Ang]

I would drop Tony's or Sci-Fi. I've never been to Tony's but I haven't had the desire to do so either. And we have eaten at Sci-Fi once and the kids weren't all that crazy about it. The food was ok but it was just sort of "meh" for us. While the cars were fun to look at and be sitting in, we found it awkward for the 2 people in the front seat to have to keep turning around to talk with the people in the back seat. It was dark. It was loud. We couldn't hear each other well. I felt like we had to yell at our waitress to place our order or to get her attention for a refill. It just wasn't comfortable for us.

 

[Aurora in blue]

Another vote for Tony's. We had terrible service and the food was not so good either. Le Cellier may be overrated but worth trying. It is the one ADR we make every trip

 

[TinkerbelleAbbysMom]

Thanks for all the replies! We have eaten at Tony's, Mama Melrose's, CP, Akershus and Le Cellier. We enjoyed them all. I ate at SciFi back in HS which was 15 yrs ago!!! We haven't done O'Hana's or Tusker House before. I originally booked Tony's as we have eaten there on our last two birthday trips. I was thinking, "Oh, it's b/c a tradition". But then I thought, we didn't actually eat there on DD's b'day last year, so not necessarily a tradition. I am leaning towards that one. But then I like the idea of just paying out of pocket for SciFi. That's definitely an option to consider too! Thanks for that suggestion!

 

[XGrumpy1]

I would drop Tusker house. That last morning is always such a mad house for us, I don't like the added pressure of making a ADR.

 

[TLSnell1981]

I would cancel, either Mama Melrose or Tony's. Tusker House is one of our favorite buffets, and Sci-Fi is fun.

 

[Q-man]

Drop Tony's. Mama Melrose's is the better Italian place. Olive Garden would be a big improvement over Tony's.

 

[Kate716]

I would drop Tony's. It was the worst food of our entire trip and we will never go back.