I chose the 50's Prime Time since you never know how your little one will react to Sci-Fi. Some kids are perfectly fine with it and it's a lot of fun. For others.. Well, not so much fun. I have a 2 1/2 year old, too.. And right now she's going through the "I don't like the dark.." stage. But like I said, you could also have a kid that is totally fine with it and enjoys the old movie clips. But for my peace of mind, I'd go to the other restaurant. And maybe go for a shake or dessert at Sci-Fi.