I always make mine in order of popularity.
When booking ADRs on day 180, the chart I use has my ADRs ranked by popularity- and then the columns to the right of each one list out the meal (b,l,d) + date, the ideal time + an acceptable range, space to fill in the time we got and finally, space to input the confirmation number.
It's not until I'm past the entire 180+10 window that I move to a chart that has my ADRs in chronological order.
A lot of this comes down to what you're booking. If you have 'Ohana dinner, Rose & Crown timed w/Illuminations, Cali Grill timed with wishes, a pre-park opening slot at CRT or Crystal Palace, or Le Cellier lunch- it's usually best to rank those towards the top. Even on day 180, I had to settle a bit. On top of that...the other day, I found that prime spots at Tutto and 50s PT were gone by the time I got to them on my list.