I'm a big horror movie buff, and the only movie to scare me big-time is the original "Night of the Living Dead." But here's why... one summer when I was off at college, I lived in this old place right across the street from the oldest cemetary in Nacogdoches (the oldest town in Texas). My roommates went away for the weekend, and I had just bought that movie. I watched it... and then spent the rest of the night watching the cemetary, hiding under the blankets, then watching the cemetary, then hiding under the blankets.... and so on. I moved out shortly after, and was very, truly frightened of that place. Just too creepy.
Now, I'm also still *kind of* afraid of the dark, and the Blair Witch Project scared me as well. Made me think twice about going camping (and I haven't since).
But all of the slasher and psychological thrillers don't scare me. Just those two movies, with "Living Dead" being the all-time worst.
-MrsAPalm