What do you tell your Kids when they ask, "Why Can't Mickey Talk?"

rick_ivnik

Mouseketeer
Joined
Oct 22, 2007
Messages
87
My DD is 3 and at our last trip she couldn't understand why all Mickey and the Gang couldn't talk. We made up some bad excuse but I was wondering what other people tell their kids? (Looking for good excuses)
 
Mickey is talking, its just that he is a mouse and our ears can't always hear what he is saying cause he squeaks so quietly!
 
you ask them why they think he's not talking. and then you'll probably have your answer.
 
We told our very inquisitive 5 year old (we are on the very cusp of believing in magical things) that it would scare the little babies if they talked. He bought it for sure. Later he was commenting "I wish those silly babies weren't so scared. I want to talk to my friends".
 

you ask them why they think he's not talking. and then you'll probably have your answer.
::yes::
That's what we always did with those kinds of questions.
I'd say "That's a really good question. What do you think?"
Kids usually come up with much better answers than we adults do. And, they are usually more satisfied with the answer they came up with.
 
great suggestion....I think I'll ask them from now on...Let them do all the work :rotfl2:
It's also better than ending up with a situation where your child may have been told one thing and starts talking about it to another child who has been told something else.
 
My son asked this very question, and this is how I handled it:

you ask them why they think he's not talking. and then you'll probably have your answer.



He decided that it's because the Mickey at the park is the pretend one and can't talk. The real one is busy making his tv show, Mickey Mouse Clubhouse.

His answer made him happy! :)
 
I'm 22 years old I have wondered this ever since I was a kid. Well, when I reached the age of understanding, I finally got it. Now what I ponder over is why, with all the technology and ingenuity and imagination that the great people at Disney have, why can't they come up with a voicebox or something that the CM's would talk into to talk to the kids (or adults in my case). I would think that with everything Disney has accomplished, this would be such a small feat. They can make a turtle on a movie screen interact with people and monsters interact with people, but they can't make a costumed CM sound like the character? Well, I guess they probably can, they just don't care to do so...I'm sure some things might be said that they wouldn't want said at some point. Who knows. I always said someday I will work for Disney and invent the voicebox to make characters talk...no one get any ideas now!
 
Talking Mickey is, of course, possible, but if you have Mickey talk, then ALL the characters have to talk. Disney has a stable of nearly 100 costumed characters that are utilized, either for shows or meet & greets, every year. Even if they only did the characters who are most often in meet & greets, that's still a LOT of characters to give voices to.

And regardless of the voicebox technology you use, having the characters talk drastically limits who you can have portray a character. People with strong accents, speech impediments, etc. would now not be able to play those characters that talk, since the technology would change the tone and style of their voices, but not the accent or lisp or whatever. So, you'd have a batch of character performers would not be able to continue. Plus ... you'd have to train those character performers on what Mickey (or any other character) would or would not say. Think about the conversations your kids have with the princesses, or Mary Poppins, or Peter Pan -- all of those characters have to think on their feet and remain in character no matter what they're asked. They pass a very stringent audition to be a talking "face character." Your audition process would change drastically if all the non-face characters spoke also, and a lot of people who are GREAT characters now would likely not make it. (Just because you can relate to kids and animate well doesn't mean you're an actor who can improvise in character.)

You're also increasing your training time, which costs money. So you've got more audition time, more training time, plus the technology and any retrofitting of the costumes (which are heavy enough without any new technology being added!). That's a big expense.

Additionally ... if the meet & greet characters were able to talk, every kid would want to talk to them, right? So now your meet & greets take up a whole lot more time. Instead of a hug and an autograph and some playtime, you've got a conversation too. Think about the difference in timing when your child meets a princess vs. when they meet Pooh, for example. And the last thing the character handlers want to do is have to pull a kid away from a conversation because they need to get the next person in to meet the character.

And then you've got language and clarity. The princesses and other face characters are "human" and can chat with a child person-to-person. A costumed character has a much harder time with that. They can't look someone in the eye and make eye contact when they talk; not all the eyes are where you think the eyes are, if you get my drift. And, since the voices are not "human" voices, but rather "character" voices, you have a problem with someone not being able to understand what a character is saying. Donald Duck's speech isn't exactly clear, y'know?

But for me, the bottom line is that the characters don't NEED to talk. I love the non-verbal communication that can be understood by anyone, regardless of what language they speak or if they are hearing impaired, or whatever. It seems so much more inclusive than giving them voices.

:earsboy:
 
old yoda is better than new yoda.

in other words, just because you can doesn't mean you should.

that's my story.
 
I must be one of the odd parents out there that take that part of the magic away from their kids at a young age. My kids know from an early age that there is a person in the costume and that TV isn't real. Santa we sit on isn't the real santa but one of santa's helpers (how else do you explain the fact Santa is in the food court and Dillards at the same time in the mall). My kids also freak out at the large characters so it helps them to know it is just a costume like at Halloween.
 
My kids never really questioned why Mickey and the other characters cannot talk, on this last trip my 5yo son asked a different "why can't" question???? Ready for this one ...."WHY CAN'T MICKEY BLINK HIS EYES?" :confused: Anyone have answers to that one? My 8yo daughter told him he does blink but its so fast that we just don't see it happening, and my son decided he really has those magicial powers we have told him about all these years!:wizard:
 
this is why i have problems with the new heads for the dream along with mickey show. they talk, move their lips and blink.
 














Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE








New Posts







DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Back
Top