Why is the virtual line concept so awful? Do more people tend to get into the virtual than a physical line?
I keep thinking about waiting forever in the heat standing on concrete surrounded by tired people and how much better relaxing elsewhere sounds.
You hit one of the issues. Regular lines are more self-regulating, as in supply/demand type balance.
As the lines get longer, far fewer people are willing to wait on them. Sure, people may wait on a 10-20 minute line for a 30-second slide... but not many will wait 60-90 minutes in the heat for a 30 second slide.
On the other hand, with virtual lines, people will be more inclined to get into the line. Since they don't have to actually stand on it. In fact, they may tap to get into the line, thinking they *might* want to ride... and then change their mind later on. Eventually leave the park before their line time even came.
This doesn't happen with physical lines.
I think the second huge issue is simply BOREDOM. Tapu Tapu is really just a fancy version of Disney's old paper fastpasses. You went to the ride, and got a fast pass for later in the day.
But while waiting for your fastpass return, there were tons of standby rides you would do.
On the other hand, at Volcano Bay... you get into your virtual line.... and other than sit around the beach or the wave pool, there may not be much to do for an hour or 2.
To some degree, this is great for Universal --- You may go buy yourself a snack and spend money, instead of standing around in the line.
But if it's --- Arrive in the park --- Sit around for 30 minutes, then first ride. Then sit around for 60 minutes, then second ride. Then sit around for 90 minutes, then 3rd ride. Then sit around for 60 minutes, then 4th ride. Then sit around for 45 minutes, then 5th ride.
So 5 rides, in 5 hours... A total of about 5-10 minutes of ride time, and 4 hours and 50 minutes of sitting around doing nothing time....
I can imagine this being frustrating.