MarkBarbieri
Semi-retired
- Joined
- Aug 20, 2006
I finally found one. It's a Delkin Ddreader 42 USB 3.0.
I did a quick speed comparison between the reader built into my monitor, my normal reader, and the new USB 3 reader. My test was copying two files totaling 1.2 gigabytes. I wrote down the throughput reported by Windows as well as the total time from when I dropped the file until the file copy dialog closed. I tested reads and writes. I used a Transcend 32GB 400x CF card for testing. The USB 2 reader and monitor went through a USB hub, which might have affected performance, although I never noticed a difference between direct connection and the hub.
Here are the times I saw:
Monitor-Write 8.3 MB/s, 2:33
Monitor-Read 9.6 MB/s, 2:13
USB 2 Reader-Write 17 MB/s, 1:15
USB 2 Reader-Read 19 MB/s, 1:10
USB 3 Reader-Write 34.3 MB/s, 0:36
USB 3 Reader-Read 90 MB/s, 0:19
Given that I will use the reader almost exclusively for reading, the 4x speed improvement is well worth the $35 to me.
Will you see the same gain? I don't know. It depends on the CF/SD card that you use. It depends on the drive you are writing to. It depends on the USB 3 implementation on your computer.
I did a quick speed comparison between the reader built into my monitor, my normal reader, and the new USB 3 reader. My test was copying two files totaling 1.2 gigabytes. I wrote down the throughput reported by Windows as well as the total time from when I dropped the file until the file copy dialog closed. I tested reads and writes. I used a Transcend 32GB 400x CF card for testing. The USB 2 reader and monitor went through a USB hub, which might have affected performance, although I never noticed a difference between direct connection and the hub.
Here are the times I saw:
Monitor-Write 8.3 MB/s, 2:33
Monitor-Read 9.6 MB/s, 2:13
USB 2 Reader-Write 17 MB/s, 1:15
USB 2 Reader-Read 19 MB/s, 1:10
USB 3 Reader-Write 34.3 MB/s, 0:36
USB 3 Reader-Read 90 MB/s, 0:19
Given that I will use the reader almost exclusively for reading, the 4x speed improvement is well worth the $35 to me.
Will you see the same gain? I don't know. It depends on the CF/SD card that you use. It depends on the drive you are writing to. It depends on the USB 3 implementation on your computer.