Mears rate: $16.00*3 ppl = $48.00 and I believe their service standard is around 2 hours?
The Uber/Lyft we took (used a different one each way from the airport because I had an Uber credit to use up, but prefer Lyft) was $49, and we arrived at the hotel within 30 mins. Didn't have to wait for the ride either, they must have a spot close by where they wait for requests, and just zoom up to the arrivals door.
We had 3 rolling bags and 2 carry-ons, and each time they had no problem arranging the luggage - even in a Prius. Worst case scenario, everyone holds a bag on their lap, if you have more luggage than we did.