Not all parents will like this one, but my DNephew loved getting those little rubberry lizards that you would toss and they would stick to the walls and the fall down. They are smushy and would fit in the pinata. It was one of his favorite things from like age 4 to 7. It doesn't damage any walls when it sticks and falls ( I know because he lived in my house)and gets gross later, but then you just toss them. I cannot tell you how much he loves these things. I am actually making a mental note to get one for his stocking next year, he is 18 now.