The Yachtsman or Narcoossee's

[softballgirl22]

Me and my mom are going to Disney Christmas 2008, and using the Disney Dining Plan. This year we really wanted to try a top place. If you had to choose, which restaurant would you rather to go, The Yachtsman Steakhouse or Narcoossee's. Both are 2 Dining plan credits. I' ve heard they are both very good, but I would like to have other peoples opinions.
Thanks

 

[Jletendre]

I've eaten at both and would have to say Narcoossee's, while the food is pretty much on par I find the setting on the lagoon perfect and a nice way to unwind after a day in the parks.

You'll have a nice meal at either but think all the little things tilt to Narcoossee's making it a memorable meal.

 

[DWDude]

Narcoossee's ROCKS!
great food and location.
Get the lobster!

 

[Pakey]

I've eaten at both and would also have to give slight edge to narcoosees. There's a bit more variety on the menu and the setting on the water is very nice. Yachtsman is just a steakhouse, found anywhere.

 

[asmit4]

Narcoossee's ROCKS!
great food and location.
Get the lobster!

Agreed!

Book on a wishes night and you can go out to the balcony and watch!

 

[OKW Lover]

We've eaten at both and you won't go wrong with either. Our preference is YSH for the overall better food, service and atmosphere.

 

[tmk0730]

We just ate at both these restaurants for the first time this past weekend. We much preferred Narcossees. The lobster is incredible and the setting is awesome.