The Walking Dead on AMC

[Minerva Mouse]

I never thought Carol was the one feeding the walkers. I never read anybody thinking she did on here either so I am confused now. I always thought they were 2 different incidents.

Sorry, didn't mean to compare the two, just meant that by process of elimination, Carol is gone, so it couldn't be Carol.

BUT, Tyrese defiantly seemed to think that the rat feeder, and the sick people killer we're one in the same. If they are, one in the same, then Rick outcast-ed the wrong person, and the killer was still among them.

 

[DisneyKentucky]

My response to tonight's episode:

 

[wdhinn89]

I wonder what Lizzie and her sisters back story is. I remember her sister saying that Lizzie was not scared, just messed up. She was a really good shot and I do not think that was something that Carol taught her. Shots fired would have been noticeable by the others in the prison and not something that could have gone unnoticed by by Rick. Carol taught the kids to use knives.

 

[wdhinn89]

Sorry, didn't mean to compare the two, just meant that by process of elimination, Carol is gone, so it couldn't be Carol.

BUT, Tyrese defiantly seemed to think that the rat feeder, and the sick people killer we're one in the same. If they are, one in the same, then Rick outcast-ed the wrong person, and the killer was still among them.

I just thought I missed something. I love coming here, getting peoples opinions and observances as well as little bits of information I missed and then rewatching.

 

[wrestlingchick26]

Most amazing episode ever. I was on the edge of my seat the whole time. Can't believe we have to wait till February to see what happened to everyone.

 

[WDWBarb]

I think Tara was driving the bus. I didn't see where she went and Maggie acted as if the bus driving off was unexpected. Not part if the "plan." And Tara was horrified by the whole thing.

I thought there were rats in the box that Bob was holding. But he acted weird about it - I think he found the box and didn't know what to make of it?

And I can think of lots of ways the blood got on that car seat...

 

[WDWBarb]

And this episode definitely hinted that Carol didn't actually kill anyone but merely took the fall for someone else...most likely the young sister (don't remember her name).

I remember thinking that there was a strong hint about this but can't remember exactly what it was. Daryl's reaction to Rick telling him that "She killed two of our own" maybe? Something in the way Daryl's face changed when he said that.

It was a great ep, I swear Chris Hardwick had been crying when The Talking Dead started. Considering his recent loss, I imagine this episode was pretty tough for him.

 

[tajz90]

I don't think the baby is dead. TWD has never shied away from emotional horror so I believe they would have tied the death of Judith into the story if she were truly dead.

 

[wrestlingchick26]

Maybe Judith got left at the prison and carol finds her, just a theory. Can't wait to see how the groups all get back together.

 

[lauradis]

Maybe Judith got left at the prison and carol finds her, just a theory. Can't wait to see how the groups all get back together.

Only about 70 more days to wait ugh

 

[wrestlingchick26]

Not that we are counting or anything

 

[anniemae]

They are all split up again like when the herd invaded the farm.

Is Daryl on his own? I think Michonne is alone too. Tyrese is with the kids. Rick and Carl are together. Don't know what happened to Maggie, Beth and Sasha. They were with Ty but I think they got separated. Glen is on the bus with a bunch of Woodbury people. I think next season they will be focusing on separate groups. I don't think they will all join up for a while.

I don't think Judith is dead. I think someone took her from her car seat and she is safe. Maybe not though. I think that would be too much if they showed a tiny baby dead or a zombie, so maybe that was the best they could do to let us know she is gone. They did not show her on the "In Memoriam" section on Talking Dead though so that makes me think she is alive, but Rick and Carls reactions make me think she is dead. Hmmmm.

 

[DisneyKentucky]

I don't think the baby is dead. TWD has never shied away from emotional horror so I believe they would have tied the death of Judith into the story if she were truly dead.

That and she didn't make the "In Memoriam."

Plus, fellow Kentuckian and show creator, Robert Kirkman kind of slipped by the question on Talking Dead last night.

 

[lauradis]

Baby is alive there was bleed but like hubby said as I was crying with Carl where's the left overs from the zombie.

 

[HonnyDipp]

I think Tara was driving the bus. I didn't see where she went and Maggie acted as if the bus driving off was unexpected. Not part if the "plan." And Tara was horrified by the whole thing.

I thought there were rats in the box that Bob was holding. But he acted weird about it - I think he found the box and didn't know what to make of it?

And I can think of lots of ways the blood got on that car seat...

Yeah, so do I. She had that "I'm so done" look on her face when she walked off. Then seconds later, we saw the bus drive off. So hopefully she grabbed baby Judith on the way out. Because I DON'T believe for a second that she's dead. With this show, there's always solid proof that someone is dead, a bloody car seat wasn't enough proof for me.

 

[elgerber]

I was also yelling at Lily for letting Megan play way over there, I couldn't believe the governer didn't say anything. Especially since she was attacked even closer just a day or two before playing with Tara. Come on people!!!
I was squirming with what he was doing to Rick, that kind of violence makes my skin crawl.
I am not sure who is where LOL, I know Glen is on the bus, but he is the only one I am sure of.
Where did Sasha go? Tyrese was last with the girls (and yes, I was shocked at her shot, Carol didn't teach them to shoot!!). Rick is with Carl. Lily and Tara may or may not be together. I loved that Lily shot him!!! Should have done that long ago.
I am wondering how long it will take them to find each other now, some are on wheels, some are on foot, and all scattered every which way.
And now Carol can't easily find them, because they are no longer at the prison.
Not sure why the governer had the prison so shot up like that, how did they expect to live in it when they won, after they took down the fences and shot huge holes in the building???
I was glad when Daryl shot Mitch, I did NOT like him one little bit.
I am still lost on the whole rat thing, not sure what to make of that. I assumed Bob has booze in the box, but it does seem odd to keep booze in a box rather than his bag.
Someone here said they thought the younger girl did it, that is Myka. You think it was her and not Lizzie?
I was concerned for a minute that Carl was dead, when Rick was screaming wheres Carl, and he was nowhere to be found. Never been so darn happy to see Carl before!!! I sure hope someone has that baby, that upset me greatly last night.

 

[HonnyDipp]

I'm hoping they all had an exit plan similar to the plan to meet up on the highway after they fled the farm. I hope they don't spend the next half of the season trying to locate each other. Cause there's still someone out there killing camps. We saw that last week. Plus, will we ever find out who was leaving the dead rats at the prison?

 

[skylizard]

I'm hoping they all had an exit plan similar to the plan to meet up on the highway after they fled the farm. I hope they don't spend the next half of the season trying to locate each other. Cause there's still someone out there killing camps. We saw that last week. Plus, will we ever find out who was leaving the dead rats at the prison?

It did sound like they had an emergency plan in place, particularly with the bus.
And yes, it's been stated by the producer that we'd find out who was feeding the rats by the end of the season. Too bad we have to wait until it starts back up in February

 

[HonnyDipp]

It just hit me...Is Hershel's head still alive? You know the Governor and his keepsakes.

 

[indimom]

As near as I could tell at the end:

Michonne is on her own. No big change for her.
Carl and Rick together.
Tyrese is with the two sisters (which could be an interesting play if one of the girls is the killer).
Daryl is with Beth.
Maggie is with Sasha and Bob (the alcoholic).
Glenn on the bus with the Woodbury survivors.
I think we'll see Lilly and Tara again, but I think they are each on their own right now.

Surely if they had a plan to escape by bus, they also had a rally point. They've certainly experienced how easily people can be lost in the past and would want to avoid that in the future. But, this could still be problematic and allow for several episodes before they all join forces again. How easily can they all get to that point on foot and will it be safe when they get there?

I don't think Judith is dead yet, but it's possible she isn't with the Woodbury or Prison survivors. I wouldn't be surprised if Tara or someone else from the attacking group picked her up. Or, God Forbid, she was left behind (hopefully behind a locked steel door somewhere.)
My proof? Sorry to put it this way, but in all the prior episodes, I've never seen a zombie walk away with it's prey. They always stop on the spot to feed. And there is always "something" left over afterward. If she had been attacked, I think some evidence would have been left behind right there.
A lot of people were shot in the attack and they could have been bleeding freely when they picked up the baby.
If she is dead, I do think they left it that way because anything else would have been too much (even for a show like walking dead).

On a side note:
DD16 spent the second half the show asking WHY they were letting Megan play in that mud all by herself. She even guessed there may be a buried zombie long before Megan picked up the sign. lol. She was completely disgusted when the poor kid died.

I hated that they all had to leave Herschel and no one could give him the dignity of a burial. I also wondered if he's still "alive." The Governor did a lousy job of beheading him, so I hope he saved him from that final indignity. Grr.