Sen. Obama Speech in Seattle, WA, Contains Misleading Attacks on Hillary
Send to a Friend »
Sen. Obama distorted Hillarys record in a speech in Seattle, WA today. The first distortion was on diplomacy. Sen. Obama said:
"Early in this campaign, I got in an argument with Sen. Clinton because I said I would meet not just with our friends, but with our enemies. Not just with leaders we like, but leaders we detested and despised. And I was told, 'oh no, you can't do that.' And I said, 'watch me.' Because I remember what John F. Kennedy said. He said, 'you should never negotiate out of fear, but you should never fear to negotiate.'" [Sen. Obama rally in Seattle, WA, 2/8/08]
This is a distortion. Hillary criticized Sen. Obama for pre-committing to a personal meeting in his first year with "
with the leaders of Iran, Syria, Venezuela, Cuba and North Korea." She never said that a president should only meet with America's friends. She also promised vigorous diplomatic efforts with all countries, friend and foe. Read more
here.
Next, Sen. Obama makes false claims when comparing himself and Hillary to Sen. McCain.
"If I'm having a debate with John McCain, he won't be able to say, 'well you supported the war, too,' because I didn't. He won't be able to say, 'you gave Bush the benefit of the doubt on Iran,' because I haven't." [Sen. Obama rally in Seattle, WA, 2/8/08]
Lets address Sen. Obamas allegations one at a time.
First: Sen. Obama begins by criticizing Hillary on Iraq. Sen. Obama does not mention that -- with the exception of Hillary's opposition to the promotion of Iraq war architect Gen. George Casey -- Sen. Obama and Hillary have identical voting records on the Iraq war. Read more
here.
Second: Sen. Obama then misrepresents Hillarys position on Iran. In fact, Hillary was one of the earliest and staunchest opponents of Bushs saber rattling on Iran, and spoke out on the issue back in February:
Hillary made a floor speech declaring that President Bush must get authorization from Congress before taking military action against Iran. [Clinton Release,
2/14/07]
Hillary co-sponsored the Webb bill prohibiting use of funds for military action in Iran without Congressional authorization. [Clinton Release,
10/01/07]
Sen. Obama missed the vote he is now using to attack Hillary. He issued a release 9 hours later and co-sponsored a similar bill in April. The bill was also supported by Sen. Dick Durbin (D-IL), a staunch anti-war Bush critic and prominent Obama supporter. Read more
here and
here.