The Case Against College Education

That is putting way too much weight on how you allow the "media standard" to make you change who you are. This is true of the "everybody has to be fit and thin" ideal and for the "smart people are too smart" idea.

If you just be yourself and don't compare yourself to the tabloids you will live a much happier life free of self-esteem issues. Self-esteem and self-image come from one and only one source, you.


I don't disagree with anything you say, but real life just doesn't work that way. The messages that the culture sends about what is valued and important DO matter and DO influence behavior.
 
A state school for 4000? Good Luck with that. :lmao:

Now you might find a smaller college that is cheaper, but 4000? That is more community college. Maybe that is what you meant?

I think I read somewhere that the average is $6000-$8000. Can't remember exactly. Either way, state schools are too expensive.

I go to a large state school and it's around $9500 for full time. I have taken classes one by one and it was over $700 for 3 credit hours. That's just tuition. Room and board runs from almost $6000 to a little over $7000, depending on what meal plan you get, that can add an extra $1000 for the year. No way would I ever pay that much money to live in a small room with someone I didn't know, and have to share a bathroom. My idea of hell. I know a ton of people who thoroughly enjoy that experience but I am not one of them.
 
I don't disagree with anything you say, but real life just doesn't work that way. The messages that the culture sends about what is valued and important DO matter and DO influence behavior.

Oh, I know they do, but they shouldn't. I don't allow the media to influence my self-esteem or image at all because I choose not to. If everyone choose not to then the media wouldn't have the influence.

We give the media the power to effect our self-image, they can't get that on their own. I just think it is silly when we then, in turn, blame the media for promoting an ideal that they only have the power to promote because we gave it to them.
 
That is putting way too much weight on how you allow the "media standard" to make you change who you are. This is true of the "everybody has to be fit and thin" ideal and for the "smart people are too smart" idea.

If you just be yourself and don't compare yourself to the tabloids you will live a much happier life free of self-esteem issues. Self-esteem and self-image come from one and only one source, you.

The problem Fire is that we're old adults :laughing: we've had time to develop our self esteem. Teenagers (my experience is with 16-19 year old girls) very much measure their self esteem by media standards. I volunteer with a group called "mission of excellence" It takes women who are in the sciences (chemist, engineers, biologist) and sends us into the h.s. to work with young girls. My company lets me spend 1 year every 7 teaching h.s. chemistry and pays my salary. These girls very much measure their self worth by what they wear, the latest phones etc etc.
I laugh because at least once a year one of the young ladies will ask if my husband brought my car for me. you should see the look when I tell them no, I went to college, got a degree, got a good job and brought it for myself. :laughing: but in reality it's sad that they think the only way for me to get a luxury car is for some one to buy it for me.
 

A state school for 4000? Good Luck with that. :lmao:

Now you might find a smaller college that is cheaper, but 4000? That is more community college. Maybe that is what you meant?

No, I actually meant a state college that is close to where we live thereby allowing my daughters to commute. They could live at home and save money on room/board. So, yes, $4000 is what I saw last time I checked about a week ago. That is tuition for a full time, in state student. To put it in perspective, out of state would be $12,000. Not too shabby!:laughing:
 
The problem Fire is that we're old adults :laughing: we've had time to develop our self esteem. Teenagers (my experience is with 16-19 year old girls) very much measure their self esteem by media standards. I volunteer with a group called "mission of excellence" It takes women who are in the sciences (chemist, engineers, biologist) and sends us into the h.s. to work with young girls. My company lets me spend 1 year every 7 teaching h.s. chemistry and pays my salary. These girls very much measure their self worth by what they wear, the latest phones etc etc.
I laugh because at least once a year one of the young ladies will ask if my husband brought my car for me. you should see the look when I tell them no, I went to college, got a degree, got a good job and brought it for myself. :laughing: but in reality it's sad that they think the only way for me to get a luxury car is for some one to buy it for me.

You know what the funny thing is? These girls don't *think* they are at all influenced by the media. My DD just had a big discussion about this in one of her classes and when she told me what all the kids said (mainly girls, herself included) I was laughing hysterically. "I won't buy this or that because some celebrity tells me to. Texting isn't necessary. Nobody needs a cell phones. I buy jeans I like. It isn't my fault they are the popular ones at the moment." Okay, Ms. itouch, skinny jean wearing, text crazed teen. So glad to see you aren't judging your worth or anyone else by their accessories. :rolleyes:
 
You know what the funny thing is? These girls don't *think* they are at all influenced by the media. My DD just had a big discussion about this in one of her classes and when she told me what all the kids said (mainly girls, herself included) I was laughing hysterically. "I won't buy this or that because some celebrity tells me to. Texting isn't necessary. Nobody needs a cell phones. I buy jeans I like. It isn't my fault they are the popular ones at the moment." Okay, Ms. itouch, skinny jean wearing, text crazed teen. So glad to see you aren't judging your worth or anyone else by their accessories. :rolleyes:

It's funny isn't it. And oh how they change.

My DD was so into clothes and purses and sunglasses in high school. She's now in college. She asked if I could send her a little extra money because she felt like she needed some new basic clothing pieces. She was going to Wal-Mart to get them!:scared1: She would never set foot in that store. Oh, how far the mighty fall!!:lmao: She thinks the Miley Cyrus line is "cute." I never would have imagined.
 
The problem Fire is that we're old adults :laughing: we've had time to develop our self esteem. Teenagers (my experience is with 16-19 year old girls) very much measure their self esteem by media standards. I volunteer with a group called "mission of excellence" It takes women who are in the sciences (chemist, engineers, biologist) and sends us into the h.s. to work with young girls. My company lets me spend 1 year every 7 teaching h.s. chemistry and pays my salary. These girls very much measure their self worth by what they wear, the latest phones etc etc.
I laugh because at least once a year one of the young ladies will ask if my husband brought my car for me. you should see the look when I tell them no, I went to college, got a degree, got a good job and brought it for myself. :laughing: but in reality it's sad that they think the only way for me to get a luxury car is for some one to buy it for me.

That may all be true, but it is still a choice that these people are making. I was the same self confident person in Jr. High and H.S. as I am now. I wore what I wanted and was into computers way before they were cool. I didn't care what I was "supposed" to do or look like and we were way to poor to have the latest gadgets.

I guess it isn't really that people shouldn't let the media mold them. If they want to fit the ideal that is fine. I just don't want people to then turn around and say the reason I want to dress like Brittany Spears or have a phone like my BFF is because of anyone other then the person in the mirror.
 
That may all be true, but it is still a choice that these people are making. I was the same self confident person in Jr. High and H.S. as I am now. I wore what I wanted and was into computers way before they were cool. I didn't care what I was "supposed" to do or look like and we were way to poor to have the latest gadgets.

I guess it isn't really that people shouldn't let the media mold them. If they want to fit the ideal that is fine. I just don't want people to then turn around and say the reason I want to dress like Brittany Spears or have a phone like my BFF is because of anyone other then the person in the mirror.

Same here - I was voted most mature every year for a reason. I was a very confident 3 year old (per my mother)... :lmao:

I am of the belief that you can look at the playground at 3 or 4 years old and pick out the future leaders. They are already in charge. The rest are happy to follow along. And, if following along means not being noticed for something, that is what they do - and this includes coursework...
 
No, I actually meant a state college that is close to where we live thereby allowing my daughters to commute. They could live at home and save money on room/board. So, yes, $4000 is what I saw last time I checked about a week ago. That is tuition for a full time, in state student. To put it in perspective, out of state would be $12,000. Not too shabby!:laughing:

The state college that I'm currently attending is about $2000 per semester for full time status (12 hours). I think I paid a little over that this semester but I'm at 15 hours and this is my last semester. Then of course books cost an arm and a leg, but that's another story.
 
The state college that I'm currently attending is about $2000 per semester for full time status (12 hours). I think I paid a little over that this semester but I'm at 15 hours and this is my last semester. Then of course books cost an arm and a leg, but that's another story.

See, I'm not crazy!:laughing: Wow, $2,000 a year is great!:thumbsup2 I too recall being very annoyed when it came time to purchase textbooks. I'm sure I looked like this :scared1: when they rang me up at the bookstore.
 
See, I'm not crazy!:laughing: Wow, $2,000 a year is great!:thumbsup2 I too recall being very annoyed when it came time to purchase textbooks. I'm sure I looked like this :scared1: when they rang me up at the bookstore.

Sorry, $4000 a year. Still, I'm reading all these others thinking I've got it pretty good. And we've got several good state colleges in the area, so I'm hoping my kids (one is probably college bound, the other one probably not) will stick close to home. Also, none of the colleges in our area are known as party schools, not that it doesn't happen though.

And this is about the same price for grad school in this area as well. Of course, on-campus housing is going to run that cost up, but for an old married woman, it isn't relevant. :rotfl:

ETA: I thought I'd make off pretty good on books this year until I realized everything I needed was new editions. No used books for me this year, which brought my total to over $400.
 
That is my point exactly. I am not a believer in the "going away" experience necessarily (even though my DD is about to do just that) because a lot of times it just turns into a 4 year drink-fest. That is not my idea of education. However, a reasonably priced education is there for anyone who wants one.
Anyone who finances a 4-year drink-fest for his college student is being stupid. Yes, any child could end up taking that route -- it's enticing! -- but if the parent realizes what's going on, sees that the student isn't progressing towards graduation, isn't making the grades . . . and continues to pay tuition for the party-hardy kid . . . that parent's making foolish choices.

A more sensible approach would be to say, "Hey, your education is obviously not your priority right now. It's time to either come home and go to community college or get a job."
Like I said, the quality at private schools is in all probability better than at state schools. However, for the $50,000 price, I would rather travel and get experiences with people from different cultures and experiences than spend it on an education I can get for a much lower cost.
This may be true in some places, but it is not really true in my state. We have a great number of public schools that're very good . . . and although we have some really wonderful private schools (Wake Forest, Duke), the bulk of our private schools are very expensive, low-quality private schools (it wouldn't be tactful to name any here). Many of our wealthy-but-not-really-smart or expected-to-go-to-college-even-though-I'm-lazy kids end up in those small, second-rate private schools. Even if money were not a question, in this area I'd much rather my children choose an average pubilc school rather than an average private school.
I work in a job that does not need a college degree; however, if you were 25 years old and trying to get my job, you would have to have a degree just for you to get your foot in the door
Yes, a degree is more necessary for our children's generation than it was for ours. I have a good friend who has a very good job and makes a good bit more money than I do, although she has no degree. She lectures our kids all the time though: "If I were your age, I'd never get my foot in the door. They'd never give me a chance. You have to be better prepared." And she's right. She also is tied to that job; she cannot go anywhere else because they won't give her a chance without the degree -- she's very lucky to be sort of "grandfathered in", but she is restricted by lack of that degree.
I've accepted that all schools are party schools if you wish them to be.
That's absolutely true.

Also, the vast majority of college students are going to indulge in SOME party-esque activities occasionally. The key is that they have the maturity to understand the limits. For example, I remember that it was pretty well accepted that all the kids in my dorm went to a certain dance club on Thursday nights (why Thursdays? I don't remember) . . . but I also remember that most of us made sure we studied ahead of time -- even up 'til maybe 9:00, and then we'd go out. Also, it's important to know when to say, "I can't go this week -- I have a paper or a test tomorrow."
Generalizations that private schools are better? They are better in some areas, such as student:teacher interaction and ratio. That isn't a generalization, it's a fact. Most private schools don't have lectures of 400 kids.
Early in my college career, I was in a number of 200-300 student lecture classes. Typically those were science classes, and we ALSO had a once-a-week lab of 20 or so students. I made As in most of those classes. I was the student who wasn't bothered by a huge class, wasn't tempted to skip, etc.

By the way, many of these classes are becoming "interactive" with Sensos, a new piece of technology that's now required in many college classes. Pretty cool stuff.
Has anyone else noticed that women can't make a decent salary without a degree but men can?
That's painting with a broad brush, but I do agree that the average man with a high school diploma only will probably have more opportunities than the average woman with only a high school diploma. That's because the world of manual labor is more open to men (greater body strength is a benefit), but I wouldn't want to assume that I'd be physically able to count on doing manual labor into my 60s. In that regard, a degree is a "safer" choice.
No, I do not think that the majority of kids go to college mainly to party. I do believe that there is a sizable portion who do.
Nah, but I think MOST college students would say, "I'm going to earn a degree, and in my down-time I intend to have fun!" The ones who are going just to have fun tend to become one-semester wonders.
 
Sorry, $4000 a year. Still, I'm reading all these others thinking I've got it pretty good. And we've got several good state colleges in the area, so I'm hoping my kids (one is probably college bound, the other one probably not) will stick close to home. Also, none of the colleges in our area are known as party schools, not that it doesn't happen though.

And this is about the same price for grad school in this area as well. Of course, on-campus housing is going to run that cost up, but for an old married woman, it isn't relevant. :rotfl:

ETA: I thought I'd make off pretty good on books this year until I realized everything I needed was new editions. No used books for me this year, which brought my total to over $400.

Are you saying you live on campus and only pay $4,000 a year for tuition, room and board, books, insurance (which seems to be mandatory on all campuses now) and other fees? If so, that is fantastic! Which state do you live in because I am going to insist DH gets transferred there. :rotfl2: However, I am guessing that you commute. Maybe I am wrong. In FL the tuition is only around $4300 a year but if you don't live near a state college, commuting is not a viable option.
 
I hire a lot of people. If I am comparing two candidates who both gave great interviews and have similar experience, but one has a college education and teh other doesn't, I'm going to hire the college grad every single time regardless of whether the job requires any college. I'll do this for two reasons. First, a college grad has generally proven that he/she can be taught. Second, when it is time to fill higher level jobs, I have an internal candidate pool who is qualified for the positions. Having an awesome employee who has no college education does me no good if the job that I'm filling requires one.

EXCELLENT point!

My husband makes 3xs what I do and I have my master's degree and DH just has a high school diploma.

College is not for everyone. It depends what you want to do as some careers require it.

I teach at a community college and we have several "AS" programs that train students to enter certain well-paying fields (mostly medical) after completing a 2-3 year program. Radiography and Sonography are examples of these. I think these are a great option for a lot of people. :goodvibes

This is where we need to define what we consider "college". If everyone here is talking about a 4 year degree fine. I would still consider someone that goes to a community college "going to college" personally.

I still say that TODAY, in THIS job market, with kids graduating from HIGH SCHOOL this year and beyond, SOME kind of post-secondary education is absolutely necessary or they will NOT get a viable job. I am not talking about the person that graduated from high school 30 years ago that now makes millions, I am talking about kids TODAY.

I agree, I can't believe people seem so shocked that kids drink in college. I went to college back in the early 80s when the drinking age was 18. We were allowed to buy kegs and rent taps from the cafeteria to have parties in our dorm. The student government used to sponsor theme parties which were $5 for all you could drink beer and mixed drinks-with students as bartenders, those drinks were strong. These things would never be allowed today.

Were there people that drank to excess then, yes. Did they turn out to be homeless alcoholics, no. They are now doctors, lawyers, successful in business, with families, community involvement, etc.

Colleges/student governments still do this, you just have to be 21 to participate :thumbsup2.

Anyone that says they didn't go to parties in college is not telling the truth. Everyone goes to parties but not everyone drinks. We went to a lot of parties and yes, we drank. Some people drank excessively but most did not. I was odd that I didn't like beer in college (and still don't) so I didn't drink at most parties because there wasn't anything besides beer :lmao:.

This isn't necessarily true. The valedictorian and salutatorian in my high school were two of the most popular kid. One was the captain of almost every sports team we had other then football and the other was prom queen.

I have always been a geek and a nerd, I am in computers, but I was never unpopular. It comes down to how you value yourself. If you are who you are and don't care what other people think you project confidence.

I agree. The most "popular' kids in our high school are also the best students. Here is is "cool" to be a good student. Heck, the marching band kids-who are all self professed geeks-are by far the most popular kids in the school.

Hey, lets talk about my local state school: University of Maryland: Last year in-state tuition was $8,053. Then you add in room at $5,549 and board at $3,826. Lets not forget books: $1,025 and $3,024 for "personal supplies" for a grand total of $21,477.

This is all off their web site. Of course everything will probably go up this year. Good Luck finding a school for $4K.

The University of Minnesota is similar in cost. DS17 is going to a smaller state school and costs for next year are $17,500 including tuition, room/board, fees, books and "incidentals". They factored $800/year for books and $2500 for "incidentals" into that total cost.

The state college that I'm currently attending is about $2000 per semester for full time status (12 hours). I think I paid a little over that this semester but I'm at 15 hours and this is my last semester. Then of course books cost an arm and a leg, but that's another story.

DS's school charges a flat rate for tuition, anything between 12-18 credits you pay the same price. They consider a full-load to be 16 credits though. Most of the costs people have posted here include everything, your cost is just for tuition.
 
I hire a lot of people. If I am comparing two candidates who both gave great interviews and have similar experience, but one has a college education and teh other doesn't, I'm going to hire the college grad every single time regardless of whether the job requires any college. I'll do this for two reasons. First, a college grad has generally proven that he/she can be taught. Second, when it is time to fill higher level jobs, I have an internal candidate pool who is qualified for the positions. Having an awesome employee who has no college education does me no good if the job that I'm filling requires one.

I also hire a lot of people. I will take a person with real life experience over college 100 times out of 100. Now, if I have 2 people, both of whom have equal life experience, and one has a degree, the college might or might not factor into my decision (unless they went to Bama ;)).

In my field (IT) a college degree isn't essential unless one aspires to become a CIO one day. I have employees with no college managing multi-million dollar budgets effortlessly. Interpersonal skills and work ethic are my most desired attributes. College degree is waaaay down the list.
 
I also hire a lot of people. I will take a person with real life experience over college 100 times out of 100. Now, if I have 2 people, both of whom have equal life experience, and one has a degree, the college might or might not factor into my decision (unless they went to Bama ;)).

In my field (IT) a college degree isn't essential unless one aspires to become a CIO one day. I have employees with no college managing multi-million dollar budgets effortlessly. Interpersonal skills and work ethic are my most desired attributes. College degree is waaaay down the list.

Ok, but how does an 18 year old or 22 year old come to you with "real life" experience? Around here you would never get an interview for an IT job without a 4 year degree from a top school.
 
Ok, but how does an 18 year old or 22 year old come to you with "real life" experience? Around here you would never get an interview for an IT job without a 4 year degree from a top school.

This is what I want to know. Last year I could barely find a job, and ended up working for minimum wage at a doggy daycare. That was all that I could find. Other places weren't hiring or required X years of experience and/or degree. HOW do you get experience if you can't get hired? (By the way, I do have marketable skills, but that doesn't seem to help much when there's nothing out there, and most of the people applying have a degree)

This is why I'm in college - I don't want to roll the dice with my life... This year I graduate and now I have many large companies looking at me.

I don't have the luxury of coming from money, my parents have struggled my entire life and still do. Me not going to college would have guaranteed me the same struggle in my opinion - it's very rare you break that cycle. I worked my *** off and got scholarships because I had to.

I guess I just don't agree that everyone who doesn't go to college will be fine if they TRY. I don't think I would have ever had a very successful life without my education.
 
Ok, but how does an 18 year old or 22 year old come to you with "real life" experience? Around here you would never get an interview for an IT job without a 4 year degree from a top school.

I am also in I.T. I worked full time for three years between high school and college to get into the workforce and figure out what I wanted to be. I went to school for I.T. (BS in Information Systems) and worked a 48 hour per week job while doing a full 12 - 16 credit hour case load.

Either of the two things I did would get someone both experience and a degree, I just chose to do both. There is no law that says you have to go right to college or that you can't work while in college. It was hard, but there is no way I would have been offered the job I was right out of college without the experience and no way I would be in the position I am at my age without both experience and the degree.
 
A state school for 4000? Good Luck with that. :lmao:

Now you might find a smaller college that is cheaper, but 4000? That is more community college. Maybe that is what you meant?

mine is less than 4000 a semester. and no, its not a community college. its also the largest university in tennessee with more than 30 thousand undergrads. its also not a bad school. we have the best aerospace program in the country.
 

New Posts





Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top Bottom