I have to agree. With our first stay at CL this past December I was worried it would spoil us to the point we would never want come back unless it was CL. While it was nice, there was really nothing offered by CL that was a "must have" for us. We are very likely going to stick with normal tower rooms at the CR when we return. CL stuff was nice to have but for us not really worth the difference in price.
I had the same feeling about the Atrium Club when we stayed 8 nights in August. When we arrived, I thought, "I am combining our favorite hotel WITH CL, it can't get any better than that!" However, I was not pleased with the way the IPO CMs seemed to be also trying to work in the lounge. They need a dedicated lounge staff and a dedicated IPO staff manning the desk. We also had many elevator problems, with some of them not wanting to go to CL and you'd have to get out and wait for another elevator (this has probably been repaired by now). Seating is also limited at peak times, such as breakfast and tables were frequently not bussed by guests or lounge staff. They should have an area with a trash can and a place to put glasses and plates so as to encourage guests to bus their table, like other CLs. Sometimes at the Regatta Club, the staff would come around and remove your plate from your table for you, so it was always very neat there. In general, I just found it to be a chaotic and rather uninviting atmosphere at the AC, unlike the WL and YC lounges. Just my own personal experience though.
There are some resorts that the cost difference between our preferred view and CL is negligible and some, such as the CR, are not.
For example, we always book Tower/BLV. The cost increase (with our 40% off) for CL is about $81/night. However, at the AKL we prefer the Savannah View. The cost to upgrade to CL there is only $24/night. The WL Courtyard View upgraded to CL is about $72/day more. DH has never stayed CL before, so that's the primary reason we've booked the OFC and because we were upgraded to it in December and I thought they have an excellent lounge.
I felt the Old Faithful Club did a much better job than the Atrium Club at keeping everything neat and tidy, replenishing the food and drinks and they had a dedicated lounge staff who were always present and working only in the lounge. I preferred the expansive lounge seating area. It doesn't have the gorgeous MKV, but I think most who book the AC book the MKV anyway so they can see that from their room. I do love the view, however, of the WL lobby from the 7th floor and the view of BL and the courtyard from the lounge windows.
Everyone values different things on their vacation, so it's nice there's something for everyone at WDW
