The 2008 American Idol Thread.....

[mandy200587]

I thought it was top 12? I may be wrong

That's hwat I thought too.

I'm going to have to start bookmarking where I leave off when I go to Nashville cause I came back to 4 pages to catch up on.

 

[disney4us2002]

So who do you want to go this week? Do you wait for the songs before you actually decide? I don't vote this early. Does anyone here actually vote? I have in the past but usually I wait til they're down to the top 4 or so. I was heartbroken over Chris Daughtry's elimination and then started voting more.

I haven't like any of Amanda's songs and I really don't like Danny but can't put my finger on what exactly he does that bothers me. I want to like Brooke because I think she's cute as a button but I don't care for her voice all that much. I'm also not thrilled with David Cook but I can't even remember his songs - I just can't stand to look at him. I think they should all pay for the stylists if they aren't yet provided, lol.

My favs so far I think are Syesha and Michael Johns.

 

[dolphindan1]

So who do you want to go this week? Do you wait for the songs before you actually decide? I don't vote this early. Does anyone here actually vote? I have in the past but usually I wait til they're down to the top 4 or so. I was heartbroken over Chris Daughtry's elimination and then started voting more.

I haven't like any of Amanda's songs and I really don't like Danny but can't put my finger on what exactly he does that bothers me. I want to like Brooke because I think she's cute as a button but I don't care for her voice all that much. I'm also not thrilled with David Cook but I can't even remember his songs - I just can't stand to look at him. I think they should all pay for the stylists if they aren't yet provided, lol.

My favs so far I think are Syesha and Michael Johns.

I really am not sure who I like vocally yet....nobody has really impressed me. not sure if its the music they are singing or is because thye are just not any good....

 

[mandy200587]

I really am not sure who I like vocally yet....nobody has really impressed me. not sure if its the music they are singing or is because thye are just not any good....

Dan don't know ya know this is suppose to be the best season yet with the most talented group of contestants yet.

 

[dolphindan1]

Dan don't know ya know this is suppose to be the best season yet with the most talented group of contestants yet.

That must be the problem....they are all so good I cant pick a favorite

 

[DarthKTrava]

Speaking of which...

So fitting..... so fitting.....

 

[DarthKTrava]

I think the 80's will be a fun week!
There is so much FUN music to choose from!
there were so many One hit wonders and big hair bands...
maybe we will get some New kids on the block! Or WHAM!,

Or we'll get another bunch of lame songs like the past 2 weeks. Especially the snoozer ones. Or the ones the band will fritz up because they SUCK! I could barely tell they were doing "Hot Blooded" if it hadn't been for the guy SINGING it. The band didn't sound anywhere like the song.

 

[DarthKTrava]

Perez Hilton found a pretty perfect image of Travolta to compare with Jason Castro

HA....here's another

But Robin I heard Ryan say a couple times this is the best talent they have ever had......

Maybe he's on delusional medication.....

CAN'T WE ALL JUST GET ALOOOOOONG??

I can't agree more!!!

 

[jacksonsmom]

Just goes to show every one sees things differently.

I, for one, am not jealous of Kady I personally think Kristy Lee is a lot prettier then Kady and probably in better shape (isn't she the one that kick boxes?), but again that is my opinion and every one has a different opinion and every one sees pretty has something different.

I still think Kady has an attitude. Not just the little clip that was shown here, but I have seen her on the side watching the others with her arms crossed over her chest or hands on her hips. It is hard to explain, but yes she comes across to me as having an attitude. That turns me off and yes, I would like to see her voted off.

Btw-- I think Danny has an attitude too, which is a reason I don't care for him. I don't like his eye rolling or head bopping at the judges.

I am just hoping with the 80s theme next week we can discuss their singing talent

 

[tarmand]

Maybe he's on delusional medication.....



I can't agree more!!!

Man, I usually don't like Perez Hilton, but in this case....he is my idol!

 

[agnes!]

Maybe Mr. Seacrest has been dipping into Ms. Abdul's stash...

agnes!

 

[NewJersey]

I haven't watched this season but my friend showed me one of the guys last night - umm he's adorable and really good. I forget his name...but I'll be watching the show now and I'll be voting for him.

 

[dolphindan1]

Maybe he's on delusional medication.....



I can't agree more!!!

I think we are all getting along but if we all agreed and had the same opinions well we wouldnt have this board or even the AI show. Its all friendly discussion. We go through it every season. Blake, Elliott, Fantasia, Daughtry leaving too soon, Pickler, Sanjaya just to name a few.

 

[Virgo10]

I haven't watched this season but my friend showed me one of the guys last night - umm he's adorable and really good. I forget his name...but I'll be watching the show now and I'll be voting for him.

I bet you saw David Archuleta.

 

[Robinrs]

I bet you saw David Archuleta.

I beg to differ!!

I'm dying to know who Tim saw! He and I have a lot of the same taste!! (ahem... Eric Bana!!! )

 

[r3ngels]

I think we are all getting along but if we all agreed and had the same opinions well we wouldnt have this board or even the AI show. Its all friendly discussion. We go through it every season. Blake, Elliott, Fantasia, Daughtry leaving too soon, Pickler, Sanjaya just to name a few.

Well said

 

[dolphindan1]

As a huge Ruben fan I am excited about him performing the farewell song. I hope this restarts his career. He has a great voice and was the 2nd best winner out of all the AI winners, Soul Patrol being the 1st. Any one know when he is set to perform? I only missed the vote off show this past Thursday so I hope he didn't perform then. Will he be on stage does anyone know? or will he just be the background song as the top 12 are voted off?

 

[TiggerPiglet]

As a huge Ruben fan I am excited about him performing the farewell song. I hope this restarts his career. He has a great voice and was the 2nd best winner out of all the AI winners, Soul Patrol being the 1st. Any one know when he is set to perform? I only missed the vote off show this past Thursday so I hope he didn't perform then. Will he be on stage does anyone know? or will he just be the background song as the top 12 are voted off?

I can't remember now if Ryan said he would perform the song that will be used as their farewell song or that his song is going to be the farewell song and we won't see him perform it Sorry, not much help.

 

[Robinrs]

As a huge Ruben fan I am excited about him performing the farewell song. I hope this restarts his career. He has a great voice and was the 2nd best winner out of all the AI winners, Soul Patrol being the 1st. Any one know when he is set to perform? I only missed the vote off show this past Thursday so I hope he didn't perform then. Will he be on stage does anyone know? or will he just be the background song as the top 12 are voted off?

Check out the Velvet Teddy Bear Now!

 

[gometros]

As a huge Ruben fan I am excited about him performing the farewell song. I hope this restarts his career. He has a great voice and was the 2nd best winner out of all the AI winners, Soul Patrol being the 1st. Any one know when he is set to perform? I only missed the vote off show this past Thursday so I hope he didn't perform then. Will he be on stage does anyone know? or will he just be the background song as the top 12 are voted off?

As much as I like Ruben and Taylor Hicks, I cannot disagree more. You cannot dispute two Grammy winners. What has Taylor been doing since he won? I'm sure I listen to the wrong radio station to hear him, so I'll admit he might be getting a fair amount of play somewhere, but I haven't heard much about him.

I don't know if this is the most talented bunch or not, it may be that they are more closely talented. At this point, I can't think of one guy I'd rather see go than another, okay maybe Danny Noriega, but that's not based on talent, but as someone mentioned earlier, I don't care for the attitude either. As far as the girls go, If Kady and Amanda go, I wouldn't be too unhappy. I think Amanda is a one trick pony and while she can find an appropriate rock song in a theme of eras, she would be terribly exposed in other theme nights. Kady just doesn't do anythinf for me.