Thanks Dave!

And cost you perhaps $150K in investment gains......


The thing is, you KNOW that you will SAVE the $100K in interest, but you MIGHT make $150K, or more or less-you just don't know. But if you don't pay off that mortgage early, you KNOW you will be spending $100K in interest.
 
But then everyone wouldn't know how smart he is.

Not smart, disciplined. It's like being 100 pounds overweight and paying someone to tell you you're fat. Some people need others to tell them the obvious before they will do something about it. If you actually have to have someone else tell you it's not good to spend more than you earn, you should save for retirement and being out of debt is better than being in debt, and you listen then you've gotten your money's worth. How smart, dumb or snarky for that matter has nothing to do with it. But I really didn't have to tell you that, did I? Now give me $100 and I'll call you enlightened :laughing:
 
The thing is, you KNOW that you will SAVE the $100K in interest, but you MIGHT make $150K, or more or less-you just don't know. But if you don't pay off that mortgage early, you KNOW you will be spending $100K in interest.

I now feel sort of dumb for investing my money when I should be stuffing it under the bed...
 
I now feel sort of dumb for investing my money when I should be stuffing it under the bed...

I don't think anyone is advocation stuffing your mortgage interest under the bed. That would take up a lot of room and get dusty :rolleyes: I think the point here is that one can invest and ALSO pay off their mortgage sooner to save $ in interest. DR has you doing that-he's not saying pay off mortgage and stuff it under the bed.
 

I now feel sort of dumb for investing my money when I should be stuffing it under the bed...

You both have good points. The only thing I can see that separates the two of you is how much risk you're willing to take. One of you is going the "guaranteed" route by paying off the mortgage and the other is taking the extra money and investing it in hopes of a higher return. Neither way is wrong, just different.
 
No, this has turned into a "I know way more than Dave Ramsey, but if you are too dumb to do it my way, I will call you names" thread.

We are very thankful to have paid off student loans and cars and are currently working on our mortgage.

We also have 401Ks and have paid 15% into retirement since we were 22. We also have investments accounts, Money Market accounts, Roth IRAs, and a general savings account to cover over 6 months of living expenses should we need it.

But what do I know? Apparently not much. :rotfl:

Dawn

To me, this kind of looked like a thread for folks proud of paying off their bills and getting a better handle on their finances.
 
No, this has turned into a "I know way more than Dave Ramsey, but if you are too dumb to do it my way, I will call you names" thread.

We are very thankful to have paid off student loans and cars and are currently working on our mortgage.

We also have 401Ks and have paid 15% into retirement since we were 22. We also have investments accounts, Money Market accounts, Roth IRAs, and a general savings account to cover over 6 months of living expenses should we need it.

But what do I know? Apparently not much. :rotfl:

Dawn

You need to take a chill pill!
 
No, this has turned into a "I know way more than Dave Ramsey, but if you are too dumb to do it my way, I will call you names" thread.

Either that or an "I'll tell folks you repeatedly go around telling people they are idiots in thread after thread when I actually don't have the slightest idea what you do" thread. :confused3

For the record, since you are too busy to find all of my "insults" on your own here is a link to the only other time I've ever mentioned Dave Ramsey:

http://www.disboards.com/showthread.php?t=2665572

and the only thing I even mentioned about his system was
I don't know. Perhaps if I had never heard of Clark Howard then Dave Ramsey would sound just great. There's certainly nothing wrong with his advice or his system.


But Abbeys_mom was right, I should have just answered your original question and left my opinion of DR out of it. I apologize to the OP for moving the thread off on a tangent.
 
Not to mention the $25 you spent on a Ramsey book, $100 on his class and $20 on envelopes.. :)

Library, no class, when I was using envelopes (now I just have line items in my interest-bearing checking account) they were just letter-type envelopes that I already had.

I don't understand why you think one needs to spend money to learn about DR.

Not smart, disciplined. It's like being 100 pounds overweight and paying someone to tell you you're fat. Some people need others to tell them the obvious before they will do something about it. If you actually have to have someone else tell you it's not good to spend more than you earn, you should save for retirement and being out of debt is better than being in debt, and you listen then you've gotten your money's worth.

Example. I grew up very poor. Dad didn't pay child support, mom lived month to month (we rented a house for 17 years, though I have to admit it was a pretty nice place for a kid to grow up...absolutely tiny but had a huge back and side yard), my mom only lived with money when she re-met her childhood sweetheart and they married (by that time I was in college).

She never had the time to teach us money management.

I never even thought about it. Hit college, applied for and got three credit cards (the first when I was 17!) when they came to campus. Did the student loan thing, just put it all off until tomorrow, didn't once think about where it would all come from.

Meanwhile, my brother spent the last 3 years of high school in the house with the new stepdad with a GREAT job, excellent pension, tons of investments. Brother is also smarter than I am (not that I'm stupid, but he's just brilliant), and thinks in an entirely different sort of way than I do, and was able to think about the future at a much younger age than I did.

Somehow, even in college, brother was working things out to create an INCREDIBLE life for himself. He has it made now. I do not.

It took FINALLY reading DR's book (free from the library) for me to somehow see HOW to get out of debt. HOW to figure out where my money should go, instead of just watching it slip away.

My husband started out in a family with money, but then his dad gave over their house to pay off a *business* debt, even though he'd been incorporated with all the protections, because he was too embarrassed to contact his business attorneys to find out what to do. So the house he'd grown up in (that his parents "owned", ha ha, ya don't OWN it until you're done with the mortgage IMO) was gone as soon as he was around 18 or so... His dad made *good* money, but it just slipped through his fingers...his dad was raised during the Depression by a father who drank and gambled his family's money away... His dad never saw good money management skills, didn't have the time to figure it out, and hubby's mom was always so interested in how things *looked* that she didn't care to know how her husband was bringing in money (when FIL died he hadn't filed taxes in 6 years but had told her he had (thank you e-filing for allowing THAT to be possible), he had taken out a 20K loan on her life insurance by forging her signature, and he didn't have any insurance on himself...all of thise to keep as much money coming in as possible to keep her in the manner to which she had become accustomed).

DH was a poor English score on the SATs away from getting into MIT (they told him that in their rejection letter), he's not a stupid man, but he never learned about money.



I'm so so SO glad that you and HHS learned how to not get in debt, how to get out of debt, and how to manage your money from such a young age.

I don't know why you have to insult those of us who didn't learn this. Obviously there are many people who DO need to read a book to really figure it out. Many of us grew up hand to mouth, with no time and no money to explore the world of money management.

DH and I had family pressuring us fro 2003 until everything crashed down around America to buy a house. They said it was so EASY to get loans, that we were stupid to rent! But, in the one big smart money-thing we did during our time together, we refused. We could rent much nicer places than we could possibly afford with a mortgage. We didn't want a "starter home", we wanted a HOME. We didn't have the money for upkeep, to furnish a place, etc etc etc. We somehow instinctively knew that it just wasn't right.

Not too long before everything went south and not long before FIL died, my MIL and FIL lost their second "purchased" home. Starting around late '07 and into '08, my father, who had finally been able to get a mortgage on a house, bought a *second* house, and then ran into problems with that house and renters and all sorts of nonsense, and he battled foreclosure on BOTH houses. He got out of that by the skin of his teeth, but they lived for an entire year on credit cards (even while my stepmom worked a good-money job, but that money just got sucked up by their crushing debt).

My good friend, who is also brilliant but had her own reasons for getting such a mortgage, faced her condo's balloon payment. etc etc.

Funny how none of those people have told us to buy a house since then...



Anyway, there are people who do need the words of someone else to help show them the way.

It's not fair of you to come into a thread where people are talking about how much a person HELPED THEM, and bash that person. If you have such great ideas, write your own book and HELP other people. But don't come in and basically tell those who have been helped that we might have flunked elementary school (and I don't remember financial planning classes in any bit of my schooling, let alone 1st-6th grades)...
 
Well, you got me there. He can be arrogant. I think his overall principals are good though and I congratulate anyone who gets out of debt no matter which program they choose.

Dawn


Isn't that the basis of every Dave Ramsey show?? :lmao:
 
I have to agree with some of the other posters. I think Dave is a crock of crap, he charges for what you SHOULD know and he is rude beyond belief. I think he preys on people who are desperate and they fund his life. My dad taught me the basics for free, he didn't need a "Dave Ramsey" to teach him. It kills me how Dave doesn't want you to spend money on anything, except his seminars.
 
I have no use at all for Dave Ramsey but if paying someone money to tell you common sense things you should have learned before you made it out of grammar school is what works for you then go for it.

:thumbsup2 agreed
 
Well, you got me there. He can be arrogant. I think his overall principals are good though and I congratulate anyone who gets out of debt no matter which program they choose.

Dawn

Dave Ramsey is a good guy overall. He could have continued to work in real estate once he figured out his finances and not helped so many people figure out theirs too. Instead, he put his story out there to show that you can look wealthy, but be dirt poor.

I've always been anti-debt. My parents always seemed to stress over money. I didn't want to spend my life like that.

I write a check for cars, even for my house, tuition, and so forth.

My husband and I do have some of our money invested in vehicles other than savings accounts. We generate more interest and we have to spread our money around a bit for FDIC purposes.

I would never gamble like that if I owed someone else money, like on a mortgage.

But that's just me.


I plan to croak with positive assets! LOL
 
Dave Ramsey is a good guy overall. He could have continued to work in real estate once he figured out his finances and not helped so many people figure out theirs too. Instead, he put his story out there to show that you can look wealthy, but be dirt poor.

I've always been anti-debt. My parents always seemed to stress over money. I didn't want to spend my life like that.

I write a check for cars, even for my house, tuition, and so forth.

My husband and I do have some of our money invested in vehicles other than savings accounts. We generate more interest and we have to spread our money around a bit for FDIC purposes.

I would never gamble like that if I owed someone else money, like on a mortgage.

But that's just me.


I plan to croak with positive assets! LOL

If he was truly doing what he does out of the goodness of his heart, he'd either give the info for free or reduce the cost.

Notice he does neither? :rolleyes1

I agree with the others that say what he is selling is common sense.
 
Not smart, disciplined. It's like being 100 pounds overweight and paying someone to tell you you're fat. Some people need others to tell them the obvious before they will do something about it. If you actually have to have someone else tell you it's not good to spend more than you earn, you should save for retirement and being out of debt is better than being in debt, and you listen then you've gotten your money's worth. How smart, dumb or snarky for that matter has nothing to do with it. But I really didn't have to tell you that, did I? Now give me $100 and I'll call you enlightened :laughing:

But what you do not realize is that overweight person will need to learn how to become healthy. It's not a matter of just walking into a gym and hitting the treadmill . It takes learning exercise routines and buying healthy cookbooks. Maybe even hiring a personal trainer to help motivate that person to get to the gym and eating the right things and get them into a healhty routine.

It is the same with financial matters. Not everyone was brought up understanding the value of money and how to spend their money wisely. So, just as that overweight person, they will need to look to someone that can help guide them to make those right decisions and get them into a financially healthy routine.

But, you can keep looking down on those that need help to get their lives in order, since it makes you feel better about yourself.
 
If he was truly doing what he does out of the goodness of his heart, he'd either give the info for free or reduce the cost.

Notice he does neither? :rolleyes1

I agree with the others that say what he is selling is common sense.

And I am sure that you do your job for free too :rolleyes1

The US Debt is $14 TRILLION

The US Private debt is over $30 TRILLION

33% of people over 65 get 90% of their income from Social Security :scared1:

1.4 million filed for bankruptcy in 2009 and many more were foreclosed on or sold short.

It seems that "common sense" and "discipline" are not too common :rotfl: The marketing power of American companies seems more powerful than most people's "common sense".:rotfl2:

If you have it, plus a good income, then be thankful. If not, then help is very valuable.

Dave had been responsible for getting tens of thousands of people out of debt. Probably having more impact on finances in America than any other single individual in the country. You may not like him, but his system works and can be understood and put in place by people with a grammar school education. If you follow it you WILL be better off than doing nothing. You can probably do better, but you will end up better off than most Americans. That is worth $10 or $70 per year or whatever.

Dave comes off as arrogant because he has helped thousands get out of debt and prosper and people call him about how smart they are and they have never helped even one person. He has built a $10M + net worth by helping people change their lives and some guy broke and in debt wants to explain how smart he is because he got $300 in cash back from his credit card. I imagine it can get frustrating dealing with people who don't get it.
 
My family are more DR fans. Love him or hate it is up to you. We have paid off debts, fully fund our retirement, live on one income(in the military), fully fund our vacations, and pay cash for just about everything. We love it. Our family thinks we are crazy but they respect our choices and asks us for advice now that the economy has turned.:goodvibes

For those of you who think he is a jerk and why pay for something you should have learned, where are you going to learn this? Think about it. I am in my 30's and my parents did not talk about money and were not good with it. I only found out about how bad they were when they went thru a divorce. Think about what people say they "need". I "need" a 52in tv with cable and all sorts of movie channels. No you don't "need" it. It is a want. You need food. I "need" a car to get around, maybe but not one that is going to cost half your paychaeck. And yes, there are people out there who think like that. People like need to be spoken to a little differantly. Telling someone to grow up and act like an adult and take care of their responsiblities, is a good thing.:thumbsup2 He is on tv, radio, and the internet. So you don't have to pay. But if you do, it is a lifetime membership, how many places do that?
 














Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top