Target employee starts online petition protesting Target's BF hours

There are tons of people out there who don't work retail that also have to work those days. Manufacturing doesn't take many vacations or holidays either. Where do you think bread and milk for the holidays comes from? Do you think dairy workers get a lot of days off? How about the people in the newspaper industry? It isn't just retail. People work 24/7 shift work all the time in a lot of different industries. I have a really hard time feeling bad for someone who has to work retail on black friday. Suck it up. Sorry.

Once again folks, read the article. He is not complaining about working black friday. He is complaining about working THANKSGIVING.

Black friday is not black friday when it starts THANKSGIVING DAY. That 's "thursday, thanksgiving day"
Better yet, is it still black friday if they post an ad in August?
 
1. Really - a 22 year old has to nap to stay up all night - does he do that before a big party too? Sorry - he lost me there - at 22 we never even left for the bars before midnight.

2. Rich taking advantage of the middle class?!?!?!? Has he never been out on a black Friday - cause I can tell you - the rich people I know will be home sound asleep in their beds b/c their time is more valuable to them than the couple of bucks they will save on BF. In my experience, while there are plenty of wonderful nice people shopping...the rude, ignorant and definitely not rich are out in full force on black Friday.

Good points!

In all fairness, it wasn't until this year that businesses are really starting to open on Thanksgiving Day and not waiting until some wee early hour on Black Friday. I don't think it's too much that he expected to have the day off.

And if we as consumers don't respect the employees time by not shopping, they will get to a point where businesses are open all day on Thanksgiving. Is that what we really want? Do you want your family missing the holiday so someone can have the opportunity to shop that day?

I LOVE businesses that are open on Tofurky Day. Without a lot of family around here, without the urge to be with the family that IS here, and as vegetarians, the holiday is kinda boring! Also, I'm not that much into football, and DH is kind enough to not insist on making my ears bleed from the sound of the games...

DH and I met while working customer service at amazon, where we absolutely knew that we would be working over the holidays. Heck, he was hired in october and I was hired in November...you KNOW we were working our rears off from the moment we were done with training!

I guess my biggest complaint would be that it seems that black friday is getting crazier by the year. People have died. It's scary crazy in these stores and as an associate/employee, you have little control. People can be animals. Fights break out all the time. You have people that haven't slept, some have been drinking, many are wired up to make it through. You have lines of 80 people where you have 5 TV's for example-
....
Next I expect that we will be open Christmas also as 364 days a year is not enough days. After all what would we do if we couldn't shop 24/7/365.:confused3

But isn't that the reason for the expanded hours? To try to calm everyone down? Of course it's not going to work, but I figured it was an attempt to spread out the madness.

And the 5 TVs thing...that lands squarely on the head of the store.

Yay for being open on xmas! I always appreciate places that are open then. I used to work those days and it was rewarding to help people. They were always so surprised that someone answered the phone...why did you call if you didn't think someone would be there, I always wondered...

ITA with all your points. And I'm with you on getting good deals in a less demanding way (online shopping works for me!)

Sure do hope you aren't ordering anything on the holidays, calling in (it's a very convenient time to call, since you're at home after all...) with questions, emailing them. You should expect it to not be picked, not be packed, not be shipped, not move an inch if it's already in transit. Accept happily that it will be there at least a day later than you wanted it to be. etc etc etc.

If you don't want people at work on those days, then you shouldn't expect ANYONE to be at work on those days. They will, of course, be at work. They will, of course, be picking and packing and shipping and moving your orders. But don't expect it, since you didn't want them to work on those days.


The bottom line is that this guy at Target is not wanting to work the holiday, but for every employee that does NOT want to work the holiday, there ARE others who ARE willing to work the holiday, either for the extra pay, to help their fellow workers, to avoid family drama, because they don't celebrate the holiday, because they have no family, or whatever. Sure, some employees have to work when they don't want to, but don't we ALL have days where we have to work despite not wanting to? When you take a retail job you KNOW that weekends and holidays are part of the deal. If you are not willing to do them, you take another job.

Yep!

PP indicated Target is having employees stock shelves on Thanksgiving.

Sounds a heck of a lot better than dealing with the public.


We need to get away from greed and back to family.

Get BACK to it? When were we IN it? When when when? There have ALWAYS been people working on these holidays. Maybe middle class, office job types didn't see them, but they were there, toiling away. Out of sight, I suppose.

Also some businesses its not really greed. Their is a DD near my sister that a few people got really loud and rude in (its attached to a gas station) about them being open on Christmas.

And what were those people doing there, at a business, on that day, if they didn't want people to be working on that day? :rotfl:

And as for Disney being closed, wouldn't it be great for all those people traveling to Florida during school vacation week in December to go to Florida, get there and have WDW closed...no restaurant to eat in, no mousekeeping, no bus transportation, no park to go to. Sit in your room quietly with nothing to do so the employees can stay home. :rotfl2: Never happen.

It would go further than that. They woudl have to leave. Because the hotel employees, down to maintenance, would have to be home. And you can't be there if no one's there. So everyone would have to pack up and leave, then come back the following day. Where would they go? What would they do? Who knows?

You're right he's not a victim. He's actively trying to change some thing he sees as unfair. Sorry but I actually have more respect for people who try to better their situation than those who just "suck it up" and "accept any type of treatment". Where do we draw the line? some one harrasses you, do you "suck it up"? Your job puts you in a unsafe or unhealthy situation? "suck it up".

He's just doing an online petition. He *wrote* for a few minutes. And put it online.

This is NOT impressive.

All he's doing is "telling on" his company. Call me crazy, but don't most people on the Dis HATE "telling on" things?

If he wanted to effect change, he should have gone through his normal channels. With his employer.

Because with this petition, all he's doing is broadcasting that he doesn't need that job, he doesn't CARE about that job. This doesn't even affect him!

I wonder how all of his coworkers who don't actually CARE that they are working that day feel about it? Because there will be some. As someone who used to volunteer for all the days that others didn't want, it REALLY bothered me when people tried to close the whole place down. There were many of us, for many different reasons, who LIKED working on those days, and we didn't want that taken away from us.
 
Please be nice to the employees that you will encounter over the holiday weekend.
 
Once again folks, read the article. He is not complaining about working black friday. He is complaining about working THANKSGIVING.

Black friday is not black friday when it starts THANKSGIVING DAY. That would be called, lets see "thursday, thanksgiving day"
Better yet, is it still black friday if they post an add in August?

:confused3

He isn't working either day so it is all moot. He is behaving as though he was scheduled that day.

Black Friday begins at midnight--which is when Target opens. Clearly IF HE WERE ACTUALLY SCHEDULED, he would have to arrive earlier than midnight so that the store would have everything ready to go. Booting up computers, setting up tills, getting everyone positioned, having the Red Shirt guard handling the line, etc...

So sure, they are scheduled on the day of Thanksgiving, but it is only so that they can open on Friday promptly at midnight.

Target is NOT starting Black Friday on Thanksgiving day. Midnight is indeed the start of a new day.
 

I worked retail during the holiday once - long before the openings became earlier and earlier - and that was enough for me.. I would clean offices & bathrooms before I would deal with that craziness again.. :eek:

But there's even consumers upset by the push back of hours. Just because they'll line up at 11pm for a 5am opening, doesn't mean they want to interrupt their Thanksgiving dinner as well just to line up at a store at 3-4pm for a midnight opening.
.

Correct.. There are articles stating that customers are upset as well - and have been signing the petition..

I guess my biggest complaint would be that it seems that black friday is getting crazier by the year. People have died. It's scary crazy in these stores and as an associate/employee, you have little control. People can be animals. Fights break out all the time. You have people that haven't slept, some have been drinking, many are wired up to make it through. You have lines of 80 people where you have 5 TV's for example-

The stores do alot of planning but it all goes out the window as customers don't care and you can't control them.

You hit the two biggest nails on the head why I stopped going out on BF many, many years ago..

People are animals - and I don't want to get crushed, stomped on, punched in the face, or run down in the parking lot - for...............

The "5 tv's" - or "our shipment didn't arrive" - or 2 seconds after the door opens for some reason "all" of those hot items were sold in 2 seconds - "we were supposed to get more"; etc., etc.. They are simply marketing ploys to get you IN the store and hopefully you will buy the more expensive models (since they don't have the ones advertised) - or wander around and purchase other items (that you had no intentions of buying prior to entering the stores)..

I can still remember how upset my parents were when department stores and malls started opening on Sundays.. This would have them spinning in their graves..
 
:confused3

He isn't working either day so it is all moot. He is behaving as though he was scheduled that day.

Black Friday begins at midnight--which is when Target opens. Clearly IF HE WERE ACTUALLY SCHEDULED, he would have to arrive earlier than midnight so that the store would have everything ready to go. Booting up computers, setting up tills, getting everyone positioned, having the Red Shirt guard handling the line, etc...

So sure, they are scheduled on the day of Thanksgiving, but it is only so that they can open on Friday promptly at midnight.

Target is NOT starting Black Friday on Thanksgiving day. Midnight is indeed the start of a new day.

Some Target employees (including the one that posted right in this thread) are scheduled to work Thanksgiving morning until around lunch time to get the store ready for Black Friday.
 
I worked retail for many years. Knowing I had Christmas and Thanksgiving was a great relief to me so I could make plans and share the days with my family.

I tried to sign the petition but it would not let me. It would not recognize any city /state that I put in the form.

Do you think someone is messing with the petition so no more people can sign.
 
I worked retail for many years. Knowing I had Christmas and Thanksgiving was a great relief to me so I could make plans and share the days with my family.

I tried to sign the petition but it would not let me. It would not recognize any city /state that I put in the form.

Do you think someone is messing with the petition so no more people can sign.

I don't think so. The number has increased by 20+ just in the last 5 mins. :)
 
There were many holidays my dad worked while I was growing up. There were many nights he got called in at 3am. I suppose if he didn't like it he could have quit. Darn people getting in accidents on holidays and during the middle of the night. :good vibes


I suppose one can complain, argue, fight it, but honestly, it won't do any good. Supply and demand run the game.

Dawn
 
I know that retail is greedy, but that is the name of the game. There are plenty of others who have to work the holidays. Growing up my Dad never had any of the major holidays off, we all survived. You know that Black Friday plays a large role in retail, so it shouldn't be a surprise if you work in retail that you may very well be expected to work on Thanksgiving. :confused3
 
There were many holidays my dad worked while I was growing up. There were many nights he got called in at 3am. I suppose if he didn't like it he could have quit. Darn people getting in accidents on holidays and during the middle of the night. :good vibes

There is no way anyone here can compare emergency personnel; police officers; nurses; doctors; the military; and other vital personnel having to work on Thanksgiving with greedy stores who lure people in with advertised items they don't have and crazy customers that will literally crush you to death because they want one of those "5 tv's"..

That's not even comparing apples and oranges.. That's comparing life & death with flat out greed..
 
I've worked retail and had to work MANY a Thanksgiving Morning/Black Friday/Christmas/New Years shift. When you work retail, you need to expect it. Whining because you have to work during the holiday season is just that... whining. Get over it and go to work or quit and let someone who wants to job have it. I won't say it doesn't suck, but it should not be a shock or surprise to anyone who works in retail... especially for a company like Target.
 
And these people just contribute to the craziness:

http://today.msnbc.msn.com/id/45360...de/t/they-lined-black-friday-days-ahead-time/

I love BF, it's a tradition with my mom and sister that started 20 years ago, but I don't like BF sales starting on Thanksgiving Day. They should start at midnight, not any earlier. Let Thursday be Thanksgiving and Friday be shopping. I agree with the PP who said that BF is getting out of control. Retailers need to quit blaming it on the consumers and own up to the fact that they want to beat the competition and make more money.
 
I won't be giving any retailer my dollars either with their early opening on Thanksgiving Day or "Black Friday" either. Greed and hunger for money is obscuring the true meaning and origins of these holidays (Thanksgiving and Christmas) and I for one, will NOT be supporting it.
 
The thing about retail opening on Tgiving...Stores are already open almost everyday of the yr, except Christms , and use to be Tgiving. What do these stores sell..JUST STUFF..Its nothing that cant wait!!! Heck Chik Fil A is CLOSED evry Sunday and Tgiving and Christmas and they arent going out of business..Sears was open last yr for the first time on Tgiving(dont know if they will be this yr) These empoyyyes shouldnt have to go to qork at ten pm and work all night just for the few shoppers that will be there,,And i work for disney and am going to be working an 11 hr shift on Tgiving, which I am not complaining about becasue disney is a vacation destination..but retail..please!! ya know..its Christmas, it isnt about buying stuff!!!
 
I read a more expanded article and it said that they felt this was the rich once again exploiting the poor and middle class so they could shop when they want. And they interviewed another 22 year old and he said he would have to leave his family Thanksgiving early so he could nap before he has to work at 11:00 pm....

1. Really - a 22 year old has to nap to stay up all night - does he do that before a big party too? Sorry - he lost me there - at 22 we never even left for the bars before midnight.

2. Rich taking advantage of the middle class?!?!?!? Has he never been out on a black Friday - cause I can tell you - the rich people I know will be home sound asleep in their beds b/c their time is more valuable to them than the couple of bucks they will save on BF. In my experience, while there are plenty of wonderful nice people shopping...the rude, ignorant and definitely not rich are out in full force on black Friday.

3. A woman who has worked for WalMart for 21 years said she was happy to work - she would get paid extra and her family has planned so they can enjoy the day together - she can get the rest she needs (I understand why she needs the rest - I'm in the home stretch to 40 and staying up all night is not as feasible as it was when I was 22) and she is happy to have a job.

I wonder who will be providing the better customer service that night?
I don't feel we can judge just because he is young! Do we know his health status? He might not be able to stay up all night and then work a 10 hour shift. And how many no sleep people do we want driving on the roads with us?
 
I woked at sears for 6 Bllakc fridays...the last yr i worked (09) they opened at 3 am!!! and i wasnt paid any differential..and u know what....the store shouldnt have bothered opening so early becasue there were literally only 5 customers who came in...and it was DEAD until 7am..the was busy til noon..then dead until closing ..so i dont see the big deal and necessity of this early opening stuff
 
Here is the thing about the hours... SOME locations will see a huge demand for it. Not all. Some locations will be dead. However, it is a lot easier for a company to say "All locations will open at X:XX" instead of trying to break it up and guess who will need the earlier hours (except for one state that has laws against it... can't remember which one atm). Plus, it's a lot easier for a commercial to give one specific time instead of having to do multiple commercials to air in specific locations.
 
I work at Walmart and the company policy is that you have to work the same shift for at least 2 weeks to receive a premium for it, so everyone working overnight on BF WILL NOT receive the extra pay unless they are a usual overnight employee. We do get paid for Thanksgiving day, though, whether we are working or not--it is based on our average weekly hours worked.

While I am a night owl, I would rather the sales started at 5 am or so like usual. Thanksgiving should be family time, not 'thanks for giving me this TV for $199' time. :confused3
 







New Posts









Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Back
Top