I'm just curious for those of you who believe that removing a child from a store gives in to them, or rewards them for bad behavior -- what exactly do you do or think happens when you take them out of the store?
When I removed my kids from a store, it wasn't play time. They sat in their car seats, or sat in the car until they settled down. No radio, no yelling from me, just sitting there quietly in our seats.
It wasn't necessarily a punishment, but it sure wasn't fun either. Sometimes all they needed was a quiet place to unwind from the overstimulation (mostly that would have been DS). DS had a big problem getting overstimulated in crowded stores or public places, so if I had no choice but to take him with me when we went shopping, I made sure to be aware of the signs when he couldn't take much more. Sometimes they just needed me to let them know their behavior wasn't okay, and that our shopping trip just got lengthened a good bit by having to sit in the car, then go back and finish shopping.
It was a huge inconvenience to me to have to do that, and fortunately I didn't have to do it on every shopping trip. I'm sorry, but it's OUR responsibility as parents to have to inconvenience ourselves when our kids need us to.
For those who inevitably bring up a disability, this works wonders for kids with disabilities. I don't mean to sound insensitive, but it's just no excuse to let your kid have a complete and total meltdown (I'm not talking whining, I'm talking full-blown tantrum or screaming meltdown). Whether or not you think it's inconsiderate of other shoppers/patrons, it's just not good for the child either.