Like a lot said above, and having stayed at both, I think the Swan gets you more bang for your buck. Also, for me, I like getting the Marriott points as well. Also, my son was once walked in on in the shower by a maid at the Boardwalk while he was in the bathtub (I had put the do not disturb on and had just left for a couple minutes). The next day, we were promised no maids would come. But, a male one tried to get in EVEN WITH the do not disturb on, but this time I had him put the chain on while I was gone and would text him when I was returning. He was so traumatized by it all, he refused to ever stay at a Disney property again. So, this is our compromise.