Survivor - Guatemala

[4greatboys]

Here are our league standing for last night:

Tribe Name: DIS Tribe



Rank Team Name Score
1 itsme4gb 1280
2 Amy45 1111
3 dazzled35 975
4 zurgswife 887
5 ThiaW 698
6 Quiltteddy 457
7 Beth112 384
8 llyolf 356

 

[cardaway]

The sad thing is that unless Jeff says something, they may never know Gary has been lying to them the whole time.

I was disappointed that Steph lied to Gary, but now they will never know. She couldn't vote for him.

 

[Mom2Ashli]

Do you think that Jamie really thought Gary said he was going to vote for him, or was he lying to the others b/c he just wanted Gary out??

I think he did it to start trouble. Get everyone talking and wondering.

Or maybe he is that dense that he didn't understand what was said to him.

 

[Mom2Ashli]

Jeff made it sound like if someone did find the idol and WANTED to use it tonight they could. So if Gary's head wasn't on the chopping block he could have kept it a secret and used it at another time.

 

[PRINCESS VIJA]

Do you think that Jamie really thought Gary said he was going to vote for him, or was he lying to the others b/c he just wanted Gary out??

I don't know... It was plain as day that Gary said he would vote WITH him and not AGAINST him... so if he got it screwed up he's got rocks in his head. I almost think he wanted Gary gone insted of Bobi John. (sp?) OOOPs, oh well.

Hmmm, a ladies alliance. That would be smart. Interesting possibilities...

 

[4greatboys]

I think they should have had the vote THEN asked if anyone had the idol. Thats what they did last time but no one had it. It would have been interesting to see what happened once they voted him out and he got to stay.

 

[puffkin]

I missed it at the end, who voted for Cindy?

 

[Mom2Ashli]

I think they should have had the vote THEN asked if anyone had the idol. Thats what they did last time but no one had it. It would have been interesting to see what happened once they voted him out and he got to stay.

Oh THAT Would have been GREAT!

 

[Mom2Ashli]

I missed it at the end, who voted for Cindy?

Gary voted for Cindy.

 

[Beth76]

I missed it at the end, who voted for Cindy?

Gary voted for Cindy. I have no idea why.

It was also my understanding that Gary keeps the immunity until the final four. I'm almost positive I heard Jeff (and another survivor) that the idol guarantees to the finaly four. But, it didn't appear that Jeff gave back the idol to Gary.

I was liking Judd OK until last night. He was almost as obnoxious as Jaime. I can't believe he would get wasted and throw up in the shelter. And I was disappointed that he chose Steph to sit at his table. I can understand BJ because they were sort of buddies and he only had a potato. Steph had a cheeseburger. I think it would have been nice if he had shared with Lydia.

I'm conflicted about Gary. I really like him as a player, but it still bothers me that he's been lying about being a football player. I'm actually really starting to like Rafe. Although, I think he's too nice to get much further. But, he did almost win immunity last night--so who knows.

 

[Planogirl]

I wonder why in the world Gary voted for Cindy? That was odd.

Bleh, I really don't have anyone to root for this year. Only people to root against. I hope that they wise up and get rid of Jamie.

 

[cardaway]

It was also my understanding that Gary keeps the immunity until the final four. I'm almost positive I heard Jeff (and another survivor) that the idol guarantees to the finaly four. But, it didn't appear that Jeff gave back the idol to Gary.

Why would he need it back? They know he has it and now they can't vote for him until the final four.

 

[Beth76]

Bleh, I really don't have anyone to root for this year. Only people to root against. I hope that they wise up and get rid of Jamie.

Yeah, but he would be a great person to go up against in the final two. I got the feeling last night that that might be Rafe's plan.

 

[Mom2Ashli]

I wonder why in the world Gary voted for Cindy? That was odd.

Bleh, I really don't have anyone to root for this year. Only people to root against. I hope that they wise up and get rid of Jamie.

That is kinda how I feel. I can't find one person that I really like and would love see win it all. And I am sorry but they better wise up and get rid of Steph. She has played before and she knows what she needs to do at this one to win the game. They all should be watching their backs.

This season is not as good as the rest of them.

 

[Beth76]

Why would he need it back? They know he has it and now they can't vote for him until the final four.

Whoever has regular immunity keeps the immunity necklace. I would assume that Gary would keep his idol. I don't know, maybe not.

 

[welovedis]

Haven't posted on this thread before, but had to say what DH & I were talking about last night.

If, indeed, Gary gets the idol back to keep until the final 4, would he still attempt to compete in the immunity challenges? If he did, and won, he could then give his immunity to anyone he chose.

DH also commented that he might keep Dani along, but not for too long because she is the one who does know his "secret" --not sure if she has said anything more about this---and could potentially ruin him in the final four with that info.

Just our .02!

 

[Good Ol Gal]

I think they should have had the vote THEN asked if anyone had the idol. Thats what they did last time but no one had it. It would have been interesting to see what happened once they voted him out and he got to stay.

Oh.. I would have LOVED that!!

 

[cardaway]

If, indeed, Gary gets the idol back to keep until the final 4, would he still attempt to compete in the immunity challenges? If he did, and won, he could then give his immunity to anyone he chose.

That's exactly how I am envisioning it works. I think they made it very clear that geting the idol got you to the final four. Winning the challenges after winning the idol would get you even more power, basically the twist the producers came up with. And I like it.

 

[welovedis]

This is what I found in the episode 8 recap explaining the other immunity idol:
"The tribe was stunned to learn there was a hidden individual Immunity idol somewhere in the jungle. The rule: In addition to any individual Immunity won at a Challenge, you can use the small stone idol to save yourself at Tribal Council. The idol must be used before the vote, and it expires when the tribe is down to the Final Four."

It doesn't say whether or not you give it back once you use it or not. Hmm.....

 

[grumpy101]

Could somebody tell me what happened yesterday on Survivor I missed it because I was Working.