I agree with you. My sister and I were at Disney this past week for Princess and I was telling her I think it would have been smarter for Disney to just raise ticket prices even more and include
Genie+. As is, we are paying more for tickets than we used to, but getting less since Fastpass+ is not included. I think had they just increased tickets the extra cost of Genie+ and said it was free (as you said), people would have complained about higher ticket prices, but probably no more than they currently complain about the higher ticket prices, and wouldn't be complaining about how bad Genie+ is for having to pay for it and not be able to get what you want. In other words, they still would have gotten their money (more, actually since everyone would be charged the $15 for Genie+) and there would probably have been less complaining than there currently is. Whoever has been making these recent calls for Disney has really been missing the mark. Having people pay more to get less is never going to be a popular decision with the customer base.