Definitely try Alfredo's.
The signature dish is quite simply the best Fettucine Alfredo you'll ever have.
I've always enjoyed myself there.
The problem with well-intentioned threads like this one is with everybody weighing in on their bad experiences, it can literally people off to a particular place which they may have had their hearts set on trying. As a result, they may miss out on, what for them could be an enjoyable, memorable time.
Use these comments the way you would a movie review.
Read them? Yes.
But go out and try for yourself!