It Really does depend on how you will spend your time. We (family with 3 young children) used a Disney all inclusive many years ago (Gold Plan, I think), and I saved all of our receipts. We definitely "used" more than we paid. That said, on our trip 2 weeks ago (Myself, DH and adult DS) I decided we would not get the value from the Sivler Plan. As others have said, if this is a trip where you would like to experience some of the things other than the parks that Disney has to offer - than yes. BUT you need to be interested in experiencing the recreational opportunities (Boats, Golf, Parasailing etc.), Spa treatments, be interested in some of the in-depth Tours or Cirque (which is WONDERFUL - by the way) and be prepared to eat at the most expensive, and therefore, perhaps, slower restaurants. Depending on what interests you, you can receive value on the Silver Plan, if it fits with your goals and your touring plans. Good Luck in your decision.