You do realize Universal is a thrill ride park, right? My local Six Flags changes up a thrill ride every year. If they don't, they won't sell tickets to the local teens they're trying to get to visit. If Universal did not keep adding rides, they will quickly become stale rides... and stale rides -- are boring.
WDW is a totally different entity. Attractions at the MK, like say POTC or Haunted Mansion - have been there for 30 years - they were never thrilling, yet, ppl are willing to travel the world over to come spend a week and experience them. To meet Cinderella. To see the castle. To be there in Disney World.
HP land is great! I am not dissing Universal at all. Just a different style of park. Universal is going to thrive on the teen crowd. Go to Disney with teens? Yes take a few days and go see HP land. Then come back to Disney and finish your vacation. That's the difference... VACATION vs THEME PARK. Tho WDW includes 4 theme parks of its own, it is a vacation destination. It is the biggest tourist destination in the world. Universal is just a park you go to cuz you live there or cuz you're taking 2 days off from Disney.
AKA. You would plan a 2-week trip to Disney to see DW and a few other local attractions which may or may not include Universal. But you wouldn't plan a 2-week vacation to come see Universal or Busch Gardens.
It's okay to love Universal and accept that it's different from Disney. Universal is about the rides. Disney World is about the vacation.
Universal is trying to be like Disney... i.e. they're adding resorts... they're trying to get you to stay on property, cuz that's how you make the money (which Disney pioneered first). But Universal's deal is buy 2 get 3rd free. Disney's is Buy 4 get 5th free, with many guests staying a week or more!
Huge difference. You have to grasp the difference between a Vacation Destination... and Universal... which benefits from being near the vacation destination that is Disney World.
I think you are giving WDW a little too much credit and selling Universal a little bit short. People are not traveling from all over the world to go to WDW. They are traveling from all over the world to visit the
Magic Kingdom. Everything else at WDW is about filling out a vacation. Looking at your attendance data
Disneyland/Magic Kingdom is head and shoulders dominate over everything else in the market except for Tokyo Disney Seas. It is the only Disney 2nd gate that comes anywhere close to the original. Everything you mentioned that people come to see is in the MK. The other parks have great rides but I can't think of 1 timeless classic. The only thing I can think of that may come close is Spaceship Earth.
Universal, is much more than an amusement park like Six Flags or Cedar Point. It is a park that is a hybrid and attempting to bridge the gap between traditional amusement park and Disney style theme park. By most accounts, the new Gringotts Coaster is going to be very family friendly similar to BTMRR and as times has gone be the Hogwarts Express is shaping up to be the real gem of the project and it shouldn't have any height restrictions.
The absolute data is not what's interesting it's the relative data. If you compare North American data from 2009 to 2012 you get the following table.
2009 Vs 2012 U.S Rankings
MAGIC KINGDOM…………………………. 2009 (1) 17,233,000 – 2012 (1) 17,536,000
DISNEYLAND………………………………… 2009 (2)15,900,000 - 2012 (2) 15,963,000
EPCOT …………………………………………..2009 (3) 10,990,000 – 2012 (3) 11,063,000
DISNEY’S ANIMAL KINGDOM ………. 2009 (5) 9,590,000 – 2012 (4) 9,998,000
DISNEY’S HOLLYWOOD STUDIOS …. 2009 (4) 9,700,000 – 2012 (5) 9,912,000
ISLANDS OF ADVENTURE……………… 2009 (9) 4,500,000 2012 (6) 7,981,000
DISNEY’S CALIFORNIA ADVENTURE 2009 (6) 6,095,000 – 2012 (7) 7,775,000
UNIVERSAL STUDIOS Florida ……….. 2009 (8) 5,400,000 2012 (8) 6,195,000
SEAWORLD FLORIDA ……………………. 2009 (7) 5,800,000 - 2012 (10) 5,358,000
BUSCH GARDENS TAMPA BAY ……... 2009 (12) 4,100,000 2012 (12) 4,348,000
IOA attendance grew by over 3 million visitors a year. Thats more growth than all 6 U.S. Disney Themeparks combined. I'm sure Universal is hoping the HP expansion with bring USF attendance in line with IOA attendance.
I have no doubt that the MK will retain top spot for the foreseeable future. Like you said, HM, POC, SplM are classics that have stood the test of time. But you are starting to see a week's vacation at WDW become a WDW vacation if a day or 2 at Universal. I'm not sure it would take all that much to tip things to a MK + Universal.